10 Point Plan – a green industrial revolution?

On 18 November 2020, the UK Government announced policies for a “Green Industrial Revolution”.  Sadly, the proposals in the Ten Point Plan are not enough to get the UK on track to get to net zero by 2050.

On 4 December 2020, WinACC welcomed the new and more ambitious target to reduce emissions by 68% by 2030 in the Government’s announcement of its new Nationally Determined Contribution to the reduction in emissions created in the UK.

But we stick to our criticisms, below, of the Ten Point Plan. We welcome your comments, agreements, disagreements or additions, to chair@winacc.org.uk.

£4bn is far too little to invest in a safe future. Germany is investing 40bn euros, France 30bn euros, this year. The UK is investing 25 times as much in HS2!

Energy sources

The proposals rely too much on hydrogen and nuclear power, and on carbon capture. It would be great if they could be part of the solution but are they realistic?

We are worried about hydrogen which may be a unicorn. Our Science and Technology Advisory Panel are studying it to see whether it has a role in getting us to zero carbon. We suspect, even if it’s produced in a green way, that it consumes electricity that would be better used as electrical power.

Transport

Phasing out new petrol and diesel cars by 2030 is good news. It’s the earliest date of any major economy in the world and in line with the recommendation of the UK Committee on Climate Change. It gives the industry a major kick in the right direction and is another step towards ending fossil fuels. But electric cars aren’t the answer. We need reliable cheap public transport, so that no-one needs to drive.

Homes

We welcome the investment in making homes warmer and less reliant on fossil fuel. We also welcome the extension to the Green Homes Grant. But the money is far too little. It will deliver only half a million retrofitted homes, when there are approx. 25 million dwellings in England alone (Government estimate 2019). We estimate it will cost about £250bn of public money, more than twice that including investment from home-owners and others, to retrofit our housing stock by 2050.

We also need a national standard for new buildings enshrined in law.

And people need training to take up jobs with the skills to retrofit or build zero carbon homes. The Government should facilitate a massive new commercial sector with money, training, R&D and regulation.

Renewable power

We welcome more support for off-shore wind, but we need on-shore wind too, and more solar power. This means that we need Government changes to planning regulations. We hope solar and on-shore wind will have access to the power auctions in 2021. We also need more investment in the national electricity grid to enable more renewable electricity, and more effort into local grids.

Land use

We’d like to see more on the role of nature, and agriculture. Using ecosystems such as peat as carbon sinks needs investment and policy.

Finance

The Chancellor’s intention to make Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) mandatory by 2025 is a world-leading step (more on this from international accountants Deloitte). But considering and reporting on the climate risk to business investments doesn’t require large business and investors to take any action. We want all financial institutions in the UK to be required by law to implement strategies that align with the Paris Agreement on climate change.

We call on the Government to put green recovery at the heart of next week’s Spending Review. This should include:

  • Diverting non-green investment into homes, low carbon transport and renewable energy – and the infrastructure and jobs to make these happen
  • A gradual, but dramatic and planned, ramp up in carbon taxes eg 5% pa.   No wavering, no false messaging to the market
  • A big increase in lifecycle tax on SUVs (which even if electric are incredibly wasteful) and other luxury goods where the price doesn’t reflect the real cost to the environment.
  • A frequent flyer tax, which was supported by the national Climate Assembly of ordinary people.

Overall, the investments listed here are far too little. Investment in in HS2, right or wrong, is 25 times as large!

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: