Hydrogen in the news
I often hear, in the news, the UK Government and political parties include hydrogen in their list of preferred decarbonisation technologies.
However, in the last couple of weeks the Guardian has published three articles which challenge the idea that hydrogen has a significant role to play in decarbonisation. These articles highlight some of the topics Brian Shorter and I discussed in a recent WinACC report on hydrogen. Thus, it was interesting to read that others have similar reservations to our own about hydrogen.
The first article reported on the H100 project to power some homes in Scotland with hydrogen (produced from water using electricity) instead of natural gas. The article reported the concerns of Alex Lee, from Friends of the Earth, that hydrogen would be too expensive and suggested an alternative approach emphasising insulation and using electric heat pumps. The second article reported analysis indicating that moving from natural gas to hydrogen could end up costing customers double what they pay now for heating. The third article questioned the feasibility of using hydrogen for domestic heating.
My view – as explained in our report – is that hydrogen technologies are perfectly valid and are the right solution in some situations. However, investing in hydrogen as a major energy source will be expensive and unlikely to significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the medium term. Producing hydrogen from natural gas, even when capturing the carbon dioxide (CCS) will still cause significant emissions, while using renewable electricity to produce large quantities of hydrogen is likely to be a very expensive way of using green electricity.
Instead, I think that domestic heating is better addressed in the short term by reducing demand for gas by measures including improving home insulation and draught-proofing, while investing in alternatives such as heat pumps in the medium term. The use of hydrogen using renewable energy should be reserved for industrial uses such as steel or ammonia production where no alternative currently exists.
Read the Hydrogen report here.
Robin Speed – September 2022
Robin is the Chair of WinACC’s Scientific and Technology Advisory Panel (STAP). If you’re interested in finding out more then please email contactus@winacc.org.uk.