The impact of Winchester’s dairy cattle on global heating

We don’t have to be vegetarians to know that eating meat, particularly red meat, and consuming dairy products contribute to global heating. Growing acres of food for cattle, which is then turned into meat or milk, is highly inefficient. Less than 4% of protein in cattle feed is turned into protein in beef although milk is better at 24%. But also cattle, being ruminant animals, produce considerable methane as part of their digestive processes. And methane is a powerful greenhouse gas with a global warming effect over 20 years which is 84 times greater than carbon dioxide. In addition, when cattle manure or fertilisers are broken down by microbes quantities of nitrous oxide, another greenhouse gas, are also produced.

So, it was very revealing in late June 2022 when, for the first time, the government’s Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS), as part of their annual publication of emissions data at local authority level, released estimates of the emissions from livestock and soil. This uncovered the surprising fact that the agriculture sector, which includes emissions from the consumption of fuels, electricity and gas as well as from livestock and soils, was the highest source of emissions in 56 of UK’s local authorities which is 15% of the total.

The situation in Winchester district is not so serious but nevertheless, on an annual basis, agriculture (at 110 thousand tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent) is the third largest source of emissions after the road transport (450 kt CO2e) and domestic (190 kt CO2e) sectors. The new figures show that livestock itself contributes around 60 kt CO2e which, in 2020, was almost 8% of the district’s total emissions.

In detail it is impossible at present to pinpoint the precise sources of livestock emissions in the district. However a look at national figures suggests that the sources are primarily likely to be cattle and sheep. But Hampshire (there are no figures available for Winchester district) has relatively far more cattle than sheep than the UK as a whole so it seems likely that cattle are responsible for the vast majority of the district’s livestock emissions. Also, most Hampshire cattle are dairy cattle, so it appears likely that most of the livestock sources in the district are dairy cattle too.

I have come across reports that some dairy cattle farmers have been struggling to be successful unless they change their practices or increase the size of their herds. Maybe the potential demise of their businesses would actually be a good thing for mitigating global warming. At least, from the global climate perspective, it is well known that it is better to consume less cattle-based dairy products such as milk, cheese and yoghurt.

Bob Whitmarsh

November 2022

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: