Life with a heat pump

Living with a heat pump – the first six months

Our starting point

A picture containing ground, building, brick, outdoor

Description automatically generated

Until last September our 4-bedroom house had been heated by a gas boiler which we had decided to replace by an air source heat pump. Heat pumps work most efficiently when the home has already been insulated to a high degree. Our starting point was 420mm of loft insulation, an insulated cavity wall, Band A double-glazing almost everywhere and well insulated outside doors. We also have a solar thermal panel but no PV panels. We had arranged for a survey under the Winchester Area SuperHomes (WASH) scheme which recommended the next steps to take, including installing a heat pump, on the road to minimising our home’s carbon footprint.

What had to be changed?

Our chosen heat pump installer conducted a thorough survey to model heat loss from the house. He recommended replacing just four 1980s radiators in downstairs rooms by double radiators. In addition, we had to install a larger hot water tank in our airing cupboard.

How much disturbance was caused?

The installation took place over four and a half days in early September 2022. Three days were spent re-plumbing pipework in the airing cupboard, where a control panel was also installed, running highly insulated water pipes between the airing cupboard and the heat pump through our loft and wiring up the heat pump to where mains electricity entered the house. A dedicated electricity meter was also installed which means we can monitor the electricity consumed by the heat pump.

Set up parameters

Our heat pump was supplied with an over-complicated, and not always clear, set of manuals. These were largely superseded by the addition of a wireless thermostat in the hall and Android compatible software which enabled us very easily to set up our desired day time and night time temperature settings. Separately, we had to set up the time of day when the domestic hot water in the tank was topped up by the heat pump and a weekly boost from the tank’s immersion heater to raise the hot water to 60°C to reduce the risk of Legionnaires’ disease. However once this setting up was done there was no need to adjust settings further.

Does it keep us warm?

The heat pump makes the house noticeably more evenly warm compared to the gas boiler it replaced. Heat pumps are slower to change the room temperature than gas boilers because they supply water to the radiators at a lower temperature. Consequently, our heat pump is on for longer than we were used to but it keeps the house at a much more even temperature (within ±0.3 °C of the set point).

What happens below freezing?

During the three cold spells in December, January and February, when the outside temperature was well below freezing, and our lowest daytime temperature was -5.5°C, the heat pump continued to heat the house adequately. As I understand it the heat pump is protected by a sensor that turns on an electrical heater to melt any ice that forms.

Is the heat pump noisy?

Outside, the heat pump’s fan is almost inaudible even from a couple of meters away. It cannot be heard from within the house and, because of the mounting on which the heat pump stands, there is no noticeable vibration either.

How much energy does it use?

The energy consumed by, and the efficiency of, an air source heat pump depends on the temperature difference between the outside air and the water being delivered to the radiators (the flow temperature). Thus, in winter months it will normally use more energy than in spring or autumn. Consequently, in the first five months of normal operation, we used between 230 kWh of electricity in October and 930 kWh in December. In all months the heat pump has consumed at least 2.3 times less energy (kWh) compared with when we were burning gas 12 months earlier.

What is the heat pump’s carbon footprint?

The operational carbon footprint of the heat pump essentially depends on the carbon intensity (kg CO2 per kWh) of the electricity supplied to it. If you buy electricity from Ecotricity, for example, the only footprint will be from the transmission and distribution losses in the national grid because all their electricity is generated from renewable, i.e. essentially zero carbon, sources. On the other hand, a boiler burning fossil fuel gas has a carbon intensity which is ten times as much!

What is the cost?

Our heat pump is predicted to have a seasonal efficiency coefficient of 3.3 which means that over a year it will produce 3.3 times more heat energy than the electrical energy it consumes (the extra heat energy comes from the air). On the other hand, as of today (1 March 2023), we pay 3.37 times more per kWh for electricity than for gas. This means that, at present, we can expect to pay 3.37/3.3 = 1.02 times more for operating our heat pump in a year than we would if we had a gas boiler. However, it is too early to tell whether we shall have achieved this over the first 12 months of having our heat pump.

What maintenance is required?

The installers recommend an annual maintenance visit. So far I have only had to remove and clean a inline filter a couple of times when the flow rate dropped off by around 10 percent. This is a very simple operation requiring a spanner and an old toothbrush to scrub the wire mesh filter.

Conclusion

We are very pleased with our heat pump. If, in future, the retail price of electricity can be decoupled from the wholesale price of gas, and consequently become relatively cheaper because so much electricity is being generated from renewable sources, we expect that the heat pump will actually become less expensive to run than a gas boiler. At any rate, our central heating system now operates with a much lower carbon footprint.

Bob Whitmarsh 1/3/2023

WinACC volunteer

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: