Is cost the only barrier to action on climate change?

Behaviour change versus cost – factors that influence people’s response to global heating

This year we have all become aware, some painfully, that rising temperatures all over the world are a threat to normal life. It is obvious that society has to act now and much more effectively to reduce global heating. What needs to be done, in the UK for example, is very clear. We need to rapidly reduce our use of fossil fuels which, as they are burnt and emit carbon dioxide, are driving the rising temperatures. Many people, hopefully including most WinACC members, realise this can be done by insulating our homes, driving less, not flying and using electricity from renewables. But then, after looking into actions we can take, maybe even after getting quotes for double glazing, a heat pump or solar panels, it is so easy to decide that the cost is too great and anyway the neighbours aren’t doing it, so it gets put off to another day.

On the other hand, it was estimated as long ago as 2007, that the cost of facing up to climate change immediately would be far less than the cost of taking action later *(1). A government report this year has even highlighted the potential benefits to the UK of pursuing net zero policies that will lead to new jobs and strong economic growth. *(2)

But is cost the only barrier to action? Is the government correct in assuming that introducing legislation to mandate certain building or vehicle standards, for example, will be a vote loser? A recent blog by a group of UK researchers who study public attitudes towards policies that will move the UK towards net zero casts doubt on such assumptions. *(3)

They say “Interestingly, the government’s reluctance to intervene in people’s lives with climate policies does not reflect public opinion. There is actually UK-wide support for net zero policies – including those that would involve lifestyle changes. Crucially, the public wants and needs the government to show clear and consistent leadership on climate change.”

The bloggers emphasise that technological solutions alone will never be enough to reach net zero – they say it is also essential for the government to carry people with them when they want us to cut our emissions. In other words, wide ranging behaviour changes will be essential. Even though few people may understand the scale of the changes that will be required they are willing to put up with necessary changes, as in war time, if they see that all sectors of society are doing so in a way that they perceive to be fair.

A survey by another group of researchers, across 24 countries worldwide, showed that highlighting additional benefits, such as cleaner air or stronger social cohesion, increased a person’s motivation to take action on climate change. *(4) Lastly, the bloggers found in a survey that in the UK people are supportive if they feel they are still left with some personal choice, their freedoms are protected, and they trust those who are implementing the policies. Only very restrictive policies are opposed, such as mandating meat-free diets, no flying or a car-free lifestyle.

The message from the bloggers is very clear. If a government leads by being consistent in its vision, in spite of setbacks, and is trusted by the electorate then significant progress can be made towards net zero. Perhaps we should all keep this in mind the next time we communicate with a politician at whatever level of government.

Dr Bob Whitmarsh

WinACC Volunteer.

References:

*(1)  Stern, N. The Economics of Climate Change: The Stern Review. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007.

*(2) Skidmore, Chris. “Net Zero Review: UK Could Do More to Reap Economic Benefits of Green Growth.” BESNZ Press Release (blog), January 13, 2023. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/net-zero-review-uk-could-do-more-to-reap-economic-benefits-of-green-growth.

*(3) Whitmarsh, Lorraine, Verfuerth, Caroline, and Westlake, Steve. “Net Zero: Direct Costs of Climate Policies Aren’t a Major Barrier to Public Support, Research Reveals.” The Conversation (blog), August 3, 2023. https://theconversation.com/net-zero-direct-costs-of-climate-policies-arent-a-major-barrier-to-public-support-research-reveals-210851?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=The%20Weekend%20Conversation%20-%202700627283&utm_content=The%20Weekend%20Conversation%20-%202700627283+CID_c9cb277aae3dd3040e86961851071acc&utm_source=campaign_monitor_uk&utm_term=Net%20zero%20direct%20costs%20of%20climate%20policies%20arent%20a%20major%20barrier%20to%20public%20support%20research%20reveals.

*(4) Bain, Paul G., Taciano L. Milfont, Yoshihisa Kashima, Michał Bilewicz, Guy Doron, Ragna B. Garðarsdóttir, Valdiney V. Gouveia, et al. “Co-Benefits of Addressing Climate Change Can Motivate Action around the World.” Nature Climate Change online (September 28, 2015). https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate2814.

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: