Proposals for development at Bushfield Camp have been submitted to Winchester City Council for planning permission.

The developers have asked Winchester City Council for outline planning permission for a large new development at Bushfield Camp. The formal consultation period for this application ended on 7 December 2023. See the application and see comments (in the documents).
Read on to find out why WinACC is concerned about the proposals. Keep reading for some suggested points to make.
The outline planning application has been submitted by Church Commissioners for England who own the land, with Lichfields as their agent.
An outline application does not provide the City Council with sufficient control to ensure that the criteria in the Local Plan are met. More below under the heading “Planning Permission”.
The climate impact of the proposed development
Emissions. Any development will add to emissions – from the construction, from using the buildings, and from transport.
Biodiversity: development will have a negative effect on biodiversity. More on this website
Transport: Based on the developers’ transport and climate modelling, WinACC calculates that the development will cause an average 4,542 additional trips, mostly by car, every day from 2027 onwards. This means that on weekdays there will be far more, probably between 10 and 20 additional cars per minute. More below under the heading “The impacts of transport emissions”.
WinACC believes that if there a development at all, it needs to be designed, built and used to produce:
- a net reduction in Winchester’s greenhouse gas emissions overall
- no net reduction of biodiversity – more on this website
- no net increase of transport emissions – more below
- a world class development, a beacon and exemplar which our great-grandchildren will be proud of. For context, see WinACC’s general position on development planning for a sustainable district
Planning permission
We fear that an outline application (for access only – everything else submitted is merely “indicative”) does not provide the City Council with sufficient control to ensure that the criteria in the Local Plan are met. WinACC is also concerned that there are many problems about the developers’ proposals for ‘access’ and that there will be no further opportunity to discuss this, especially the massive growth in transport emissions, if outline permission is granted.
The outline application describes the development as a “knowledge quarter” and includes employment/ research and development/ academic uses/ academic accommodation/a hotel/ ancillary uses including nursery/ shops/ restaurant/café/ bars/ visitor space/ exhibition space/ leisure and sports uses”.
This is a much wider range of uses than the current Local Plan said would be acceptable. The wide range of proposed uses goes way beyond the low key employment uses in the Local Plan (section WT3). So the proposed development is likely to have a much more significant impact on the landscape, on traffic, air quality, and biodiversity.
What does the Local Plan say?
Policy WT3 of the Local Plan allocates land at Bushfield Camp as an employment site. Therefore, whilst the site is in an area designated as countryside and a strategic gap, the principle of development is accepted.
Policy WT3 emphasises that this is a sensitive site and lists a number of criteria that need to be met. Those of particular interest to WinACC are:
- Promote non-vehicular access/ minimise and mitigate impact on strategic highway network;
- Exploit the site’s proximity to the South Park and Ride to access the site without reliance on the private car;
- Include Sustainability Appraisal and Habitats Regulations Assessment to consider potential effects on biodiversity;
- Prepare a green infrastructure strategy to enhance the development and mitigate potential impacts on the water environment and biodiversity;
- Be of exemplary design and configuration so as to have an acceptable impact on the setting of Winchester, the South Downs National Park and the wider area;
- Maximise use of sustainable construction techniques and materials.
The Planning Committee will have to assess applications for planning permission under the current Local Plan section on Bushfield Camp, until the next Local Plan is adopted.
The application justifies itself by saying that a draft new policy (draft Policy W5) which is proposed in the draft of the next (emerging) Local Plan represents “the Council’s direction of travel”. However. this policy has not been adopted. It must first go to public examination. It is at an early stage and therefore has little weight.
The new Local Plan is currently predicted to be adopted in 2025. Before that, there will be another consultation on the draft Local Plan (“Regulation 19 plan consultation”), and then an “Examination in Public” in 2024. See the draft of the next Local Plan section on Bushfield Camp (November 2022).
What are people concerned about?
WinACC’s concern is the climate impact of any development on this site. Other groups are concentrating on other aspects such as the best use of the site, the effect on views and the setting of Winchester, history and heritage of the ancient city, facilities for dog-walking, exercise, physical and mental health, what the local community wants, how the site can deliver added social value, and more.
For background, see what people said at the public meeting on 28 January 2023: click here for papers and reports.
The climate impact of the proposed development
Any development will add to emissions – from the construction, from using the buildings, and from transport. Development will also have a negative effect on biodiversity, which goes hand-in-hand with the climate crisis.
WinACC believes that if there a development at all, it needs to be designed, built and used to produce:
- a net reduction in Winchester’s greenhouse gas emissions overall
- no net reduction of biodiversity – more on this website
- no net increase of transport emissions – more below
- a world class development, a beacon and exemplar which our great-grandchildren will be proud of
For context, see WinACC’s general position on development planning for a sustainable district.
The impacts of transport emissions
WinACC has submitted an obvection to the planning applicaion obecaise of the transport implcaion on the cimate. See our objection, with details about our reasons..
In summary, our notes say:
- We must reduce all emissions sharply to achieve net zero by 2030. Transport emissions are nearly half of all emissions in Winchester District.
- The outline planning application doesn’t adequately quantify the transport emissions associated with this development, despite detailed references to policies on reducing greenhouse gases at national and local level.
- Compared with 2022, the modelling suggests traffic volumes will increase by between 17% and 37% on roads around the development by 2039. The application does not make any practical proposals for limiting the increased transport emissions due to the development– not only in response to the City Council target of net zero by 2030, but even to achieve the UK Government’s Net Zero Development Plan target of reducing 2022 transport emissions by 76% to 85% by 2039.
- The outline planning application will undermine the City Council’s Carbon Neutrality Action Plan. There must be no increase in transport emissions on the scale caused by this proposal. Based on government conversion factors, the increase in traffic will produce 6.15 KtCO2e extra emissions every year. To get to net zero transport emissions by 2030, transport emissions need to go down by 67 KtCO2e a year every year until 2030.
- Winchester City Council recently made a submission to the M3 junction 9 inquiry that the increase in emissions associated with that project were working ‘in the opposite direction’ to achieving the Carbon Neutrality Action Plan target. Clearly the same comment will apply to this scheme, and the City Council should not allow this scheme to ‘present further difficulties’ for the Carbon Neutrality Action Plan.
- The Sustainability Statement makes vague proposals about mitigating the damage caused by increased transport emissions, but does not demonstrate satisfactorily how these proposals will contribute to emissions reduction.
Next steps
WinACC will take all opportunities to influence what happens at Bushfield Camp, including communicating with the land owners, the developer and their consultants, Winchester planners and the Planning Committee, and those who decide what goes into the next Local Plan about this site (relevant only if a planning application is not approved under the current plan).