Hampshire Minerals and Waste Plan – Please respond to the latest consultation to have your say – especially on oil and gas extraction in Hampshire.
Following on from our campaign in August 2023 to stop the pumping of oil and gas across the South Downs, the next steps in making that happen are to respond to the consultation regarding this Hampshire Minerals and Waste Plan. The Minerals and Waste Plan is the document that sets out the position of Hampshire County Council as to whether or not to allow the pumping of oil in Hampshire.
What’s the urgency?
The latest consultation started on the 09 January 2024 closes on 05 March 2024.
However, they have also said that if anyone submitted responses to the previous consultation they must be resubmitted to be considered (see question 8 in the latest FAQs).
What is the new consultation?
Since the last consultation on the Minerals and Waste Plan in 2022/2023 Hampshire County Council (HCC) have put out this new consultation.
The previous consultation was called a ‘Reg 18 consultation’ (see call to action) and WinACC, amongst others, submitted comments (WinACC’s comments are summarised here).
HCC has now made some changes to the Plan, although WinACC is not clear which, if any, responses have been taken into account.
The new consultation is called a section 19 consultation which HCC is obliged to carry out before submitting the Plan to the Secretary of State for approval.
How can I respond?
The Section 19 consultation website is here.
The latest Plan is located here. This is the main plan document and contains the statements of the various policies WinACC is responding to, but there are many accompanying documents which you may find relevant.
Please note that it looks like the 23 December 2023 version is the final version for consultation – people might have seen a previous version that has now been superseded.
If you can respond please be aware, as noted above, that no previous submission made by you before February 2023 will be considered (unless your points are already covered in the latest Regulation 19 version).
Once you have looked at the consultation web page, the Plan document and the latest FAQs (which are easy to miss) you can consider making a submission.
Please read the next section before developing your responses as they must be submitted using the special form downloaded from the website. Otherwise you will likely waste time having to re-format your responses.
How to make a submission
The Plan document is very long, and we suggest you focus on the areas and policies you are interested in.
- Go to the Regulation 19 consultation website.
- We suggest if you want to make any substantive points you avoid the survey.
- Instead click on the Response Form link and download the Word document.
- This document, as explained on the website, can be emailed to hmwp.consult@hants.gov.uk or posted to the address given.
- Please note that you must fill in a separate document for every Policy or Section you wish to comment on.
- We have created an example submission form here.
What should I say?
Obviously, you can make any points you think important.
- The more evidence or arguments you can supply to justify your point the better.
- It is important to remember that there is no harm in repeating (in your own words) what others have said. Also, your points don’t necessarily have to represent a consistent or complete set of changes – it is the planning authority HCC’s job to put the whole plan together.
If you are interested in the parts of the plan relating to oil and gas extraction, you might want to consider the following policy sections which WinACC is planning to respond Policy 24: Oil and gas development and surrounding text paragraphs 6.112-6.124.
- This is the main policy relating to oil and gas development in Hampshire. It essentially re-iterates the UK government’s rationale for domestic oil and gas extraction.
- WinACC thinks that this section fails to take into account the need to urgently cease extraction and the emissions caused by actually burning the fuel extracted (see WinACC’s proposed response for further details).
- Policy 1: Sustainable minerals and waste development
- This should reference climate change explicitly by referring to Policy 2.
- Policy 2: Climate change – mitigation and adaption
- This is potentially a strong policy although people might want to consider ways of tightening it. Arguably it conflicts with Policy 24.
- Also, carbon neutrality is not defined – in fact the entire document seems to lack definition of many important terms.
- Policy 5: Protection of the countryside and valued landscapes
- Again, it’s not clear what, for example, a ‘valued landscape’ is.
- Policy 8: Water management
- People might want to consider this policy in the context of onshore drilling in Hampshire where potentially contaminated water is produced while drilling.
Other relevant links
- Hampshire Minerals and waste Plan page. Technically this the plan is developed on behalf of the various planning authorities listed at the top of the main plan document.
- Nation Planning and Policy Framework (NPPF) – this is referred to in parts of the planning document.
- The previous Reg 18 consultation and summary report and responses (NOTE – this does not contain WinACC’s responses to the Reg 18 consultation (or presumably most other responses) – just selected, redacted responses from 3 parties).