The following blog has been written by a former Chair of Trustees for WinACC, Jock MacDonald. Jock explains the book is for a general reader and he feels it is pretty easy to understand.
His review:
Legacy: How to Build the Sustainable Economy (Cambridge University Press, 2023) by Professor Sir Dieter Helm – DOI: 10.1017/9781009449229 The book is open access and free to download: https://creativecomms.org/cclicences/
This a very important book, by a very important economist. Despite that, it is written for general readers like me. Helm is a long-time Professor of Economic Policy at Oxford who has specialised in Energy and advised the Government. Over the years he has become increasingly concerned with Climate Change and the Climate Crisis. He is now angry. Thirty-two years ago, at the United Nations Conference in Rio, Climate Change, caused by the burning of fossil fuels, was pronounced to be an existential threat to mankind. Yet fossil fuels still account for 80% of humanity’s energy production, the same percentage as in 1992. It is true that there is more sustainably produced energy than there used to be, but this is more than matched by the energy produced by fossil fuels. Helm believes that this way of living is not sustainable and in a generation’s time we shall be faced with dire consequences.
I liked the book. It gave me a huge sense of relief; at last, somebody in a position of both knowledge and influence is telling truth to power. Two years ago, I wrote a personal memoir trying gently to get my readers interested in the reality and science of climate change. But Helm is somebody with real clout. He is indeed telling truth to power from a position of knowledge and power. Without people in power understanding the climate crisis, not much progress will be made by the rest of us who do understand it.
It is unusual that this groundbreaking book has been aimed at a general readership and that the academic and scientific detail will be published later in a learned tome. There are good reasons for this. People in a democracy must know what the future holds and how to confront it. And we have only one generation in which to turn the world ship of state around. This is so important that Helm has jettisoned the type of economics that he has been involved with in his career: the economics ofthe great figures of the 1920sand 1930s like John Maynard Keynes and Friedrich von Hayek, who lie behind almost all the economics taught nowadays. Because the natural capital of the environment was never considered important in their way of thinking, Helm believes that they are out of date, responsible for short term thinking, treating debt as a dangerous mechanism fit for quick fixes, in effect not fit for the present day. Yet it is their thinking that permeates the mindsets of world politicians, industrialists, businessmen, and the media. It is no wonder that he believes that he won’t be popular with many of his colleagues.
The book is essentially about people: Citizens with rights and responsibilities, and young people as The Next Generation. It is about passing on to the next generation capital assets that can be sustained, like forests and fish-stocks, all forms of communications, a world without pollution that depends on such pollution that is likely to take place, being paid for by the polluter whether by organisations or individuals, of a world where natural assets like river systems, agricultural soils and coastlines are understood and looked after. Whereas the outdated thinking is concerned with flows of money, capital, and assets, all subsumed in Gross National Product, where unending Growth encouraging consumption is the holy grail, the new thinking is likened to The Domesday Book, with a balance sheet, in which the Growth is judged by the growth in the understanding of new dangers and opportunities, and consequently proper, practical technical inventions. Good education is the key to this. Helm believes, rightly in my view, that the future is too uncertain for some fixed theory to define what is needed. Each generation must see for itself what is likely to be needed in the next generation, but not for the generation after that. Choices will have to be made of the right strategies with which to go forward. The Precautionary Principle will need to be in front of minds, if what seems to be an excellent strategy or invention might have some existential defect.
In his quiet, articulate way Helm shows us hope. After all, we do have one generation to go before the full weight of the climate crisis hits us. These will be the years for the forty-year-olds: not for Biden, rump, Johnson, Xi, Putin, Assad or Netanyahu. Think rather Rishi Sunak or Rachel Reeves, and people younger than them.
Also of great importance are Equity, prompt Payment for Pollution, and Debt. For humanity to survive on a world with straightened resources, those with least wealth must be able to live a life sure of their basic subsistence. Helm endorses a substantial national living wage. He is not afraid that this will encourage a class of lotus-eaters; people, he thinks, will instead want to work for their sense of identity, society, and fulfilment. Huge debt is a problem. At the moment it tends to be passed on to the next generation. Politicians use it to woo voters with tax reductions or increased benefits and for short term gains. It also provides easy meat for lobbyists. The UK is particularly in debt both at the level of state spending and in individuals’ finances. Pollution could be said to be a form of indebtedness: not just pollution of our rivers, soils, and oceans, but the air too. Much of that is caused by the wealthy with their propensity to air travel, house enhancement, and ease of spending. That the polluter should pay while pollution takes place, rather than at an ill-defined future, is very much a theme in Helm’s desire to stabilise the economy for the next generation.The book is indeed for the general Reader rather than the trained economist. Helm has a worry that, even so, he might have included too much that is for the expert. Little bits of it were difficult, but they did not seem to impact the general theme. More worrying for him, as he admits, was that many of his colleagues would not like his change of view on Economics. But as a general reader, I very much liked the way he paced the book. The twelve chapters were broken up into small sections, each dealing with a specific subject. Helm was an excellent navigator, alerting his crew to what lay ahead on the journey and how it fitted into what his vessel had passed. Above all, I liked the clarity of his prose.
The big questions are: Is humanity at all ready for this? Or will it, whether willingly or unwillingly, go down kicking and screaming?
Review by Jock MacDonald