A Small Modular Reactor (SMR) is defined as a small nuclear reactor producing anything from 10 megawatts (MW) to 300 MW of power. This compares with a peak output of some 3000 MW from the Hinkley C station under construction. By comparison a medium sized solar farm may have a peak output of some 25 MW.
For some years now there has been talk of SMRs being constructed in many parts of the world, including here in the UK.
As with all conventional nuclear power stations SMRs use nuclear fission where atoms are split to produce heat. SMR technology has evolved from reactors used in nuclear submarines. These have received government support and subsidies in the UK. With a new government from July 2024 promising a faster reduction in fossil fuel use, it is likely that SMRs will be talked of more. This note gives some information about them.
Small modular reactors:
- can be constructed mostly from “modules” made in a factory, which can “mass produce” elements of the reactor, thus bringing down cost. Most of the reactor can be transported from a factory to the site and assembled there far more quickly than the large one-off construction used for a traditional nuclear power station
- need a much smaller area of land than for equivalent renewable energy installations
- need much less cooling water than a conventional nuclear power station
- can have their output increased by adding additional modules, as necessary
- can be designed to use a convection cooling system, so that powered pumps are not required. If power should fail, as was the case at Fukushima, then the cooling system would still work
- can be kept cool in an emergency more easily than a large nuclear plant
- can need refuelling less frequently, even though the nuclear fuel used and waste produced is expected to be similar to conventional nuclear power stations.
Why are governments proposing the construction of small modular reactors?
Like conventional nuclear power stations, SMRs can produce a continuous stream of energy. This is particularly valuable because wind and solar, the main fossil fuel free alternatives, are intermittent.
Aside from valid concerns about all nuclear power and associated waste, the advantages suggest that SMRs could become a valuable source of fossil fuel free electricity.
But it isn’t that straightforward:
- Far from a standard design emerging, there are currently about 80 different designs in the world, according to the European Commission and Wikipedia.
- Nuclear power tends to be expensive, substantial subsidies are generally needed and cost overruns are common. For example, existing government contracts suggest nuclear power from the planned power station at Hinkley Point C could be as much as three times as expensive as offshore wind by the time it enters service.
- It is uncertain that SMRs will be cheaper than current nuclear production although economies of scale may bring costs down in future.
- The security issues surrounding nuclear power generally are harder to police when there are many scattered sites.
Where are the existing SMRs?
At present the only operational SMRs are a floating one in Russia, and a pair in China; although there are numerous pilots planned – for example in Scotland.
What are the prospects?
For those prepared to accept more nuclear power in our carbon-free energy mix SMRs may provide a valuable option. However, it seems unlikely that any will come on stream in the UK before the 2030s.
The climate crisis is too urgent to wait for SMRs to be built. We have more readily available options today for producing low carbon energy and reducing energy demand; although there are challenges to overcome to address wind and sun intermittency.