Reasons to install a heat pump – saving money, energy or carbon or for warmer healthier homes
In Sweden, Norway and Finland, which have the coldest climates in Europe, four in ten households are currently heated by a heat pump.
According to the latest data the UK has now reached quarter of a million certified heat pumps installed but this is only around one in a hundred of all homes.
This remarkable mismatch shows how much more can be done here in the UK to install these fossil-fuel free, electrically driven, central heating appliances. The independent Climate Change Committee says that to get back on track to the government’s 2030 climate target, the proportion of homes in the UK with heat pumps should rise tenfold.
The new Labour government realises this and are consulting on ending gas boilers being installed in new build homes after 2025, although existing boilers will be allowed to run on.
A heat pump can be fitted to almost any age or type of house. See examples here. Some former planning restrictions, called permitted development rights, on heat pump installations, regarding their size, location and noise, are being relaxed from early 2025.
Why install a heat pump now?
For many people, especially those with a gas boiler coming up to the end of its average 10-15 years lifetime, now is the time to consider installing a heat pump. Heat pumps are predicted to become the main source of heating for new homes, as the government looks to achieve its ambition to install 600,000 heat pumps a year by 2028.
So, why not to get ahead of the inevitable rush to meet government targets and decide to install a heat pump today?
Government grants of £7,500 are available (until March 2028) to greatly reduce the cost of the installation of a heat pump. Other grants are available to eligible homeowners under the Warmer Homes Scheme.
The most common option people will want to consider when replacing their gas boiler is with an air source heat pump. Other options, not discussed further here, are air-air heat pumps, which generate warm air and ground source heat pumps which are more efficient, but are more expensive to install.
Reasons to install a heat pump
There are many reasons why you may want to install a heat pump but they mostly fall under four headings. Scroll down on the ones that most appeal to you.
• You want to save money
• You want to have a warmer and healthier home
• You want to save energy
• You want to cut your carbon footprint
To save money
Heat pumps are relatively expensive to install but potentially cheaper than a gas boiler to operate. As already mentioned the £7,500 government grant can go a long way to reduce the cost of installation to a homeowner. This may include not only the heat pump itself but also some new radiators and a larger hot water tank.
When working, an air source heat pump typically uses 2.6-2.7 times less energy (the kWh or units that appear on your bills) in a year than a gas boiler. However a snag here is that since electricity is up to four times more expensive (per unit) than gas the bills from a heat pump can be up to 4 ÷ 2.6 = 1.54 times more expensive.
The charity Nesta explains that there are two reasons for this. First, the price of electricity tracks the cost of gas, even if one is buying 100% renewable electricity, because the cost of gas generation sets the wholesale price of electricity. Second, electricity, unlike gas, currently has a levy imposed on it to pay for renewable energy projects aimed at reducing the UK’s carbon footprint. However, the electricity:gas price ratio, one of the highest in Europe, is recognised by government to be a problem and it is likely that it will have to be decreased eventually to encourage homeowners to move away from gas.
Although heat pumps have other benefits this extra cost is putting people off installing a heat pump. However, to some extent, it can be mitigated because some suppliers, e.g. Octopus, provide an electricity tariff with three low rate periods per day. Plus, if a heat pump is turned off during the three most expensive hours of 4pm to 7pm each day, the average electricity price is effectively reduced and a lower price ratio will be achieved. Another saving can be made by converting all your cooking appliances that use gas to electricity and disconnecting your gas supply thereby saving on paying the gas standing charge.
Homeowners presently using oil or liquified petroleum gas for heating are more likely to save money because the electricity:fuel price ratio is these cases is more favourable.
It is hard to give more certain conclusions about running costs as the prices of energy are relatively volatile at the moment. However it is clear that using mains gas, a polluting fossil fuel, for domestic heating will gradually cease in the next 15 years or so. As demand increases the price of heat pumps may also fall.
At least one company offers reduced mortgage payments to homeowners who install a heat pump. One survey has shown that making a home more energy efficient, such as by installing a heat pump, is likely to increase its market value by at least 1%. Another survey suggests the figure is 3-4% for homes with an EPC rating of A or B.
To have a warmer and healthier home
A heat pump will keep your home warm just like any other central heating system. A big difference however is that it circulates water at around 45°C, somewhat cooler than from a gas or oil boiler. For this reason larger (usually thicker) radiators are required in some rooms to give out the heat required. It also means that the heat pump warms up the home more slowly, but just as effectively, as a gas boiler. The heat pump can be programmed, often using an app, and even with special WiFi or smart radiator valves to keep rooms at the optimum temperature(s) for the occupants and to take advantage of the variable tariff rates during the day.
Installing a heat pump also opens up the possibility of disconnecting the gas supply after converting any gas cooking appliances to electricity. This avoids indoor air pollution from the gas boiler and cooking which can contribute to breathing problems.
Living in mouldy properties can cause respiratory illnesses, allergies and asthma which can sometimes be fatal. To ensure the air in your home is changed on a regular basis it is advisable to install a small, but very economical, extractor fan in the kitchen and bathroom that runs all the time. This will ensure that moist air from cooking and washing is continuously removed and it will greatly help to reduce condensation indoors on windows and outside walls. As a result there is less chance for mould to form. Warmer air holds more moisture especially if the room temperature is set to at least 18°C..
To save energy
An air source heat pump which runs on electricity will definitely save energy even if the electricity is not 100% renewable. The reason is the way in which a heat pump operates. In principle a heat pump will deliver around three times more energy in the form of heat than the electricity which it consumes could do directly (such as from a storage heater).
A heat pump gets its heat from the outside air for free. Electricity is used only to run a compressor to extract this free heat and to transfer it to water (or air) and for a pump (or fan) to deliver it to the home.
If a heat pump is run on 100% renewable energy, such as from a solar farm or wind turbine, then it can be argued that, other than accounting for the energy required to build, install and connect up the renewable technology including the heat pump itself, it is energy free.
Typically the lifetime of these renewable technologies, solar farms and wind turbines, is at least 20 years so the impact of the energy used in their manufacture is spread over many years.
In operation, an air source heat pump typically uses 2.6-2.7 times less energy (kWh or the units that are in your bills) in a year than a gas boiler. A heat pump usually has its own electricity meter so this can be easily monitored.
To cut your carbon footprint
A boiler, which burns oil or natural gas, or LPG which may be derived from oil, releases the harmful greenhouse gas carbon dioxide (also called carbon here) that causes climate change. So switching to an electrically driven heat pump, which is around three times more efficient at producing heat, will always reduce the carbon footprint of your heating.
A further advantage of installing a heat pump, if you are switching away from natural gas, is that gas is mostly methane, another greenhouse gas even more powerful than carbon dioxide. Methane is particularly bad for the environment, as detailed in this article by WinACC on methane escaping from local oil wells.
The carbon intensities (how much carbon is produced when a fuel is burnt) of gas or oil are constant (gas produces 183 grammes carbon dioxide per kWh and oil 247 grammes carbon dioxide per kWh). Electricity is different because it depends on a mix of renewables, nuclear, gas and imports which varies from hour to hour with the weather and the demand for electricity.
For the UK the average carbon intensity of electricity in 2023 was 162 grammes carbon dioxide per kWh. So you can immediately see that the carbon intensity of electricity is less than that of either gas or oil. But because a heat pump running on electricity is around three times more efficient at producing heat than a gas boiler it means that a heat pump has a carbon footprint which is very much smaller than that of a gas boiler.
But, even better, if you buy 100% renewable electricity, often called green electricity, from your supplier you could claim that your carbon intensity, and therefore your footprint, has dropped to practically zero! Unfortunately, this may be too simplistic an approach as explained here by Carbon Independent.org who suggest it might be better to allow only a 25% reduction for using ‘green’ electricity. However, it is certain that as the UK invests in more renewables and the contribution to electricity generation from fossil fuels, which contributed only one third of the total energy in 2023, the carbon intensity of electricity will continue to fall.
The embodied emissions of a domestic heat pump (these are the harmful greenhouse gas emissions caused by manufacturing the heat pump) are relatively small. These emissions are offset by the emissions savings made, relative to a gas boiler, within the first year of operating the heat pump.
Cutting your carbon footprint by installing a heat pump is one of the most impactful things you can do to reduce the amount of greenhouse gases you are releasing into the atmosphere and to do part of your bit for future generations.
Bob Whitmarsh
January 2025