It is often said by our politicians that “the genie is out of the bottle” and that it is not possible to stop people
from flying and that technology will solve all of the problems of flying. Indeed, this is the view expressed by
our MP Steve Brine at a recent virtual lobby, organised by the Climate Coalitions as part of
#TheTimeIsNow campaign, asking for a green recovery.
A recent report from the Committee on Climate Change said that, unchecked, aviation would be the UK’s
biggest emitter by 2050. It also highlighted another important issue: British people take more international
flights than any other nationality, despite having less than 1% of the world population. We also know that
70% of flights in this country are taken by 15% of people 1 making support for this industry a subsidy for the
well-off.
Behaviour Change
We have seen that it is possible to stop people from flying – where awareness exists, and alternatives
exist, flight bookings go down. In Sweden there was a 9% drop in flying in 2019, before coronavirus hit.
Changing our habits is possible. 64% of flights are for leisure – trips that can easily be replaced by other
means. Much of the problem is that people simply are not aware of the alternatives, because governments
have supported and subsidised the airline industry and cheap flights have become so much a part of many
people’s lives. It has taken us little more than a generation to simply forget that there are alternatives. But
the more environmentally aware we grow, the more people will be searching around for alternatives, all of
which exist. Within Europe, travelling by train is easy, quick and pleasant – a much nicer experience than
flying.
Behaviour change is possible as has been shown with the change in attitude towards smoking. When it
became clear smoking was a public health risk, government used a combination of legislation, tax and
public health education to persuade people to stop smoking. Those who continue to smoke do so fully
informed, and far fewer people smoke. These tools should be used to change the way, and frequency with
which, we travel.
Emissions
The Committee on Climate Change (CCC) has advised that in order to meet the requirements of UK
climate legislation, aviation emissions should be no higher in 2050 than they were in 2005 and that
“aviation is likely to be the largest emitting sector in the UK by 2050, even with strong progress on
technology and limiting demand.”
Government data 2 shows that total aviation emissions for the UK grew by 4.8% between 2010 and 2016.
The most recent CCC Progress Report 3 shows emissions growth from 2016 to 2018 of 8.3%.
The aviation industry’s narrative of growth and reduced emissions is simply false. The only certain way to
reduce emissions, at the moment, is to reduce flying.
Technology
Clearly technology can help aviation to become more efficient and innovation can help the industry to
reduce emissions. We can and must look at this, but it is not the silver bullet. We need to be slashing our
carbon emissions now, not relying on techno-fixes that may or may not deliver the promised savings at
some point in the future.
Electric planes have an enormous environmental impact because of the materials required for batteries. It
is thought unlikely that they will ever have a range to be truly useful beyond super short haul (e.g. domestic
flights). In addition, commentators have said that we can have electric cars, or we can have electric planes,
not both.
Sustainable alternative fuels currently make up less than 1% of fuel used in the industry 4 and are used at a
mix of less than 50:50 with kerosene. These are considered to be too expensive to be viable for the
foreseeable future.
Biofuel from waste, which you mentioned on the call, has other drawbacks, relying as it does on fossil fuels
to create the waste it requires, and creating emissions in the production process. Moreover, the plant you
referred to on the Humber does not even have planning consent yet, so once again, the solution is several
years away.
Carbon capture and hydrogen are also hailed as the solutions but have been talked about for over a
decade and are neither viable nor scalable yet. As for offsets, the key issue is timing – we need the
reduction in carbon emissions to be now – the offsetting through afforestation and other projects is in the
future… too late.
The Time is Now
The problem is time. We cannot wait for these technologies. To reach Net Zero, we need nearly 10%
reduction in emissions until 2050. The aviation industry believes it can continue to grow because other
areas will take up the shortfall. We can get close to that through reduction, not techno fixes. The only way
to reduce emissions significantly and realistically is if we all make the decision to fly less.
It is not possible maintain growth in flying and be carbon neutral. It is absolutely essential that flying be
substantially reduced. This also means an end to airport expansion, an end to aviation fuel subsidies, a ban
on internal flights where there is a rail alternative, introduction of a frequent flyer levy, government support
for rail and ferries and a public education campaign to clarify the dangers to the planet of flying.
For more information on flying less: flightfree.co.uk
Sarah Gooding
WinACC Trustee, July 2020
To oppose expansion of Southampton Airport https://axosouthampton.wordpress.com/
1 DfT Statistical Release 2014
2 https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/final-uk-greenhouse-gas-emissions-national-statistics-1990-2017
3 https://www.theccc.org.uk/publication/reducing-uk-emissions-2020-progress-report-to-parliament/#supporting-research,-
charts-and-data
4 https://www.economist.com/the-economist-explains/2018/03/15/why-arent-all-commercial-flights-powered-by-sustainable-