Carbon Pawprint

A Dog’s Carbon “Pawprint”

I discovered recently that in 2009 a book was published that suggested that the land required to produce the food for a medium sized dog annually was about double the land required to produce the energy to run and construct a Toyota Landcruiser annually, averaged over its life. That sounded amazing to me, and very important if true. So I looked into it a bit further; but considered greenhouse gas emissions, rather than land areas.

I’m not a dog owner, but have been in the past; and I do know quite a few dogs and their owners, and I like most dogs – and most owners!

I started off with the observation that some dogs are fed a lot of meat (which seems natural, as their ancestors ate, and their wild cousins eat, meat almost exclusively). The meat is generally from frozen packs or from tins. However, many are fed dried food, which includes some meat or fish. I’m sure many are fed both, and other things as well.

A typical 400g tin of meat for a dog contains 40 – 50% meat, and the recommendation for a medium sized dog of 10 – 15 kg, say a cocker spaniel or Welsh corgi, is a can and a half, so about 250 – 300g of meat per day (well over half a pound).  The same applies to frozen packs, and so presumably to meat sourced in other ways, and is about 2 – 3% of the dog’s weight.

Dried dog food typically contains about 15% meat or fish. A typical recommendation for the same sized dog as above is 180 – 250g per day; so about 27 – 37g of dried meat or fish. The weight of fresh meat or fish is typically reduced by 70% in the drying process, and so the recommended amount of fresh meat or fish is about 90 – 120g per day, so a little less than 1% of the dog’s weight.

It has been argued that the pet food industry tends to use meat that would not have been used for human consumption. However the UK the Pet Food Manufactures’ Association (PFMA) says that “members use byproducts of the human food industry that come from animals slaughtered under veterinary supervision”. Indeed, some manufacturers advertise their “human grade” ingredients; so we must assume therefore that the emissions due to meat production are the same whether it is for human or animal consumption.

What about the carbon footprint of the meat? Well, it is very difficult to get a consensus on this, as it depends what is taken account of in the assessment, and exactly how the animals in question are raised. Partly because of the methane produced by cows and sheep, the carbon footprints of beef and lamb are generally a lot higher than those of other meats and fish (a lot of which is farmed).  If we use a probably very low figure of 10 kgCO2eq per kg of average meat produced (there are sources that put this figure into the 30s for beef and lamb), then the yearly carbon “pawprint” of our cocker spaniel’s or Welsh corgi’s meat is about 1000 kg, or about 380 kg if fed on dried food. And that’s ignoring the tins, or time in the freezer, and other food and packaging!

In passing, the Carbon Trust estimates that about a fifth of the average UK personal carbon footprint comes from the food we eat. That’s something like 2,000 to 2,500 kg per year.

A Labrador retriever, a popular dog, arguably also a medium dog, weighs some 30 kg, two to three times that of our cocker spaniel. On the same basis, its “pawprint” would be some 2,500 kg or 1000 kg per year respectively – quite possibly three times this figure if the meat it eats is exclusively beef or lamb. And some dogs are a lot larger than Labrador retrievers. So – wow – a very large dog that eats beef or lamb could easily have a “pawprint” of well over 10,000 kg (10 tonnes)!

The lifetime emissions of an average UK small to medium petrol car are of the order of 3,100 kg per year, including manufacture; and the diesel SUV equivalent figure is some 4,000 kg.

So perhaps it’s not easy to show that the 2009 book was definitely correct, but it’s not too far off!! 

There’s some food for thought.

In fact, while we are on the subject, in 2016 Energy Saving Trust research found that 53% of dog owners and 47% of cat owners leave the house heating on during the day to keep their pets warm, while 26% turn the radio on, and 15% the TV, to keep the pets company. This could add £140 a year to bills. However, veterinary associations advise that neither room heating nor radio/TV are likely to be beneficial for the pets and may actually distress them.  

 

Brian Shorter, STAP member.

 

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: