When discussing decarbonisation locally, moving to clean transport systems is always high on the agenda.
Chris Gillham, Winchester Friends of the Earth, writes:
COP27 theme. Transport and climate action. Some thoughts.
[The world is] “on the highway to climate hell with our foot still on the accelerator”, UN secretary-general Antonio Guterres at COP27.
How governments deal with Transport is a bellwether of their seriousness in tackling climate change. Governments everywhere and especially in the UK, seem incapable of addressing the addiction of wasteful and unnecessary transport. Why such an addiction is regarded as such a sacred cow that it cannot be restrained, is a mystery, though it is partly explained by a deep mythology concerning its economic importance, which has been promoted ever since the Second World War by a lobbying process as effective and as insidious as that of the arms industry. The following bullet points are intended to question this mythology.
- The problem: Transport accounts for a very large part of current greenhouse gas emission and, so far, has shown the least tendency to reduce those emissions.
- The problem is worsening: Both road and air traffic are predicted to rise significantly.
- It ought to be the easiest problem to solve: Of all economic sectors road and air travel are probably the most discretionary activities. Most of it is a use of energy that can be avoided, by a combination of behaviour and policy change, in a way that domestic, educational, workplace and hospital heating, for example, or fuelling manufactory processes, cannot easily do so. A great deal of travel could be avoided altogether, much more could be made more efficient through the use of public transport and even more avoided in the longer term by spatial planning that connected people to their employment and recreational activities in an energy-efficient manner (as opposed to the entropic distribution of activity brought about by the current road transport disposition.
- Externality: Road and air travel are very highly subsidised. The idea, for example, that the motorist is highly taxed is a myth, that politicians seem incapable of correcting. Both forms of road and air transport (including freight transport) have very large externalities. Road transport, for example, externalises more than 3 times the total tax and duty take on the activity*(1). The subsidy is essentially, indeed outrageously, regressive, in that the poorest do not have the benefit of it and suffer the greater part of the externality.
- False economic assumptions: growth: Government always asserts that there is an overall economic benefit to the nation from growing road and air transport, but there is no real evidence behind the assertion. The government has never demonstrated that building roads, for example, contributes positively to the economy and, indeed, has never countered the evidence that it contributes negatively. It relied on its own-commissioned Eddington Report8(2), which acknowledged that road building and road transport activity correlated with GDP, to assert that GDP grows with road building. In fact Eddington was careful to point out that he did not know in which direction the correlation works. There is evidence that in time-series data, increases in road building correlate negatively with subsequent growth figures in GDP over a time scale of about 15 years. The government has never countered this evidence.
- False economic assumptions: no accounting for externality: Eddington specifically said that transport externalities should be paid for by the users of the transport. Calculation shows that if road users paid the true costs of their activity, then the elasticity of price and demand would be such that road traffic in the UK would fall to levels pertaining in the 1950s8*(3). It is likely that most air transport would similarly cease to exist if it paid its true costs (for example, it is very easy to guess what would be the effect of charging a very modest [say 1p] compensation to a person under a flight path for the noise the person suffers from one flight – figures of around £200 supplement per passenger on the aircraft would arise for this single externality of the aircraft flight).
- New Climate Change Denial: The most notable feature of all government thinking on meeting its supposed net-zero ambition, is a nice cosy narrative, that acknowledges the existence and anthropogenic cause of global warming, but which asserts that no behaviour change is necessary to achieve net-zero. All we need to do is anticipate the technology that will solve our problem. Thus we can carry on indulging in and increasing our aviation and road transport habits because those habits will be cost-free in carbon terms. This equivalent of the low-tar cigarette illusion of a previous age, manifests itself in the fantasies of the government’s Jet-Zero initiative and the Decarbonisation of Transport Strategy’s reliance on EV technology:
- Jet Zero: This relies on several assertions, including the notion of ‘sustainable aviation fuels’. Again we are thrown a cosy line that this includes waste products like used cooking oil, when the reality of biofuels means the growing of crops, i.e. diverting land from growing food, when its scarcity is already leading to deforestation. The second assertion is efficiency gain from technology improvements, but growing aircraft use has always outstripped the technological efficiency gains of the past (see Jevons Paradox below). The third element of Jet Zero is magic thinking – solar planes etc. But the main element of the government’s thinking on Jet Zero is actually the usual cop-out of net-zero planning – offsetting. If off-setting means more than simple accounting fiddles and is actually about finding ways to capture carbon, then the question to ask is what extra element of carbon capture can the aircraft industry bring about that we shouldn’t be doing anyway?
- EVs: The government’s Decarbonisation of Transport strategy is that we will carry on driving more and more and we will build more and more road capacity, because the vehicles using that capacity will be net-zero. Disregarding for the moment that EVs have large embodied carbon (that the UK government does not usually count) and that their technology has very large environmental costs apart from the climate ones (lithium, rare earths etc. – the extraction of which have major resource costs, exploitative social costs and political reliance on dangerous people), the power source assumptions behind the planning for large scale EV use are highly suspect. The government’s policy essentially relies on there being enough renewable energy to feed the growth of road traffic they wish to bring about and that road transport will have priority access to such renewable energy as becomes available. Given that road transport energy use is intrinsically more discretionary than energy use in other essential activities, this is exactly the wrong priority. Road transport ought to be the last candidate in the overall economy for renewable energy.
- Efficiency – Technological Efficiency – Jevons Paradox: Victorian economist William Stanley Jevons published The Coal Question, showing that efficiency improvements in the use of coal in Scotland between 1830 and 1863 led to an increase in its demand, not a decrease as simplistic economic thinking would predict. We do not yet know whether this ‘Rebound’ effect is likely to result from the increased efficiency of EVs over ICE vehicles. But it is worth observing that a similar consequence of simplistic government thinking has long been demonstrated in road transport. The government’s appraisal method for assessing road building schemes, asserts that an appropriate cost-function for economic minimisation is what it calls the ‘generalised cost’, a linear sum of fuel cost and travel time. The inappropriateness of this measure was demonstrated by David Metz*(4), who showed that the result of road building was not that motorists reduced their travel times for a given journey, but that they spent the same amount of time travelling further (a finding that on its own comprehensively destroys the government’s whole road investment justification). It cannot be deduced that the greater distance travelled in the same time secures new opportunities for motorists that can be regarded as economic gains. The most likely interpretation is that greater distances are travelled (with greater resource and externality implications) for the same economic purposes. The effect can be observed at local levels – facilities (shops, hospitals, education, employment etc.) have tended to move further away from where people live. No beneficial economic opportunity is gained by closing the village shop or bussing schoolchildren long distances.
- Efficiency – Behavioural and Organisational Efficiency: Obviously in a sustainable future it would be better to use the most energy and carbon efficient technology available, but that is not the issue. If we were to sit down with a blank sheet of paper and decide from scratch, as a systems engineering exercise, how to organise an efficient surface transport system, we would not sensibly think ‘let’s have millions of individual vehicles, occupying huge amounts of space and constantly getting in the way of each other and more importantly, preventing much other human intercourse’. You wouldn’t do it for example, if you were setting up a new major, extensive theme park and needed a transport system to make it work. A systems engineering approach would inevitably settle on a transport disposition that combined longer journeys by appropriate mass-transport, with last-mile journeys by simple space and energy efficient movement, such as cycling and walking. A systems engineering approach to freight movement would come to similar conclusions – mass transport (rail/canal/ coastal shipping etc.) for longer journeys, last-mile delivery by transhipment to small vehicles.
It is a sign of just how dysfunctional government transport policy is that it is the massively inefficient, massively externalising and massively uneconomic road transport system that gets all the funding (currently over £100B is committed to expansion of the road network), whilst public transport and mass-transport freight networks are starved of investment.
*(1) Several studies of which the biggest was the Blueprint 5: The True Costs of Road Transport ; Maddison D, Pearce D, Johansson O, Calthrop E, Litman T &Verhoef E; Earthscan, London 1996. The climate change costing now would undoubtedly be reckoned as a lot higher than it was at the time of Blueprint 5.
*(2) Sir Rod Eddington’s advice to Government; December 2006: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/896799/UK_Research_and_Development_Roadmap.pdf
*(3) See P Kinnersly; World Transport Policy and Practice; 20.2/3; May 2014; p75 et seq
*(4) Metz, David; ‘The Myth of Travel Time Saving’, Transport Reviews, 28:3, 321 – 336; 2008