Council Climate Plan Scorecards – check how your Council compares

The Council Climate Plan Scorecards went live in February 2022!

Climate Emergency UK assessed and scored all UK councils’ written Climate Action Plans, creating the Council Climate Plan Scorecards. They say, “we found that 85 of the UK’s 409 local authorities don’t have a valid plan. And the others are of varying quality and ambition with the average score for all UK councils around 50%. “

To help us see how our local Councils have done compared with other Councils, WinACC has produced an Excel spreadsheet of the rankings exercise by Climate Emergency UK.

  1. On the first tab is a complete listing of all 408 UK councils, listed alphabetically, showing where they came in the 326 ranks. 82 councils ranked equal bottom with zero points. This is useful to look up a specific council.
  2. On the second tab are authorities in Hampshire, including Southampton, Portsmouth and the Isle of Wight. This helps us discuss how local  councils compare.
  3. On the third tab are all authorities in rank order, so we can see which authorities are worth benchmarking with.
  4. On the fourth tab  are councils by organisation type and then rank order, repeating the Climate Emergency UK presentation.

Hampshire Climate Action Network looked at Hampshire County Council on the list of all Councils (tab 3).

Hampshire County Council ties third on the ranging of County Councils, which looks impressive. However, County Councils score badly compared with all other types of Council. So if you look up Hampshire on the list of all Councils, you see that they rank 117 out of 326 councils, scoring 51% in a range that start at 92% and goies down to 3%.

There are some impressive documents HCC might emulate. Check out the Isle of Wight, and the West Somerset and Taunton document by Manchester University and the Tyndall Centre.

You can use the links in the Excel document to get to all the papers held by Climate Emergency UK. You can check the marking criteria by clicking on the underlined words at the head of the columns,  and you can look up all the plans collected by Climate Emergency UK, and on which they have based their evaluations, by clicking on the name of the authority and then clicking on the blue button labelled “See which plans were marked.”

This assesses only the structures and documentation in place. What will matter will be how well the plans are carried out.  An assessment of the success or otherwise of these plans will be important – and more difficult.

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: