WinACC’s regular monthly open meeting for February 2023 explored the question of whether direct action is the way to get action on the climate crisis. Direct action means different things to different people. So, for clarity, direct action doesn’t mean rolling your sleeves up to do something like growing your own veg – which is of course a good thing to do.
Direct action is political pressure that can be either violent, or non–violent such as, for example, sit-ins, boycotts.
The meeting heard moving accounts from local speakers George and Hazel representing Just Stop Oil (JSO), a separate organisation from XR, about why they felt that civil resistance was the right approach for them in fighting climate change. “Just Stop Oil has a simple demand – no new oil and gas – a demand backed up by the International Energy Agency, IPCC, UN and Climate Change Committee.”
“The most important thing for a parent is to protect their children. I have three sons. They may not survive to old age – the situation is so grave”, said Hazel.
“Civil disobedience for Just Stop Oil means disrupting business-as-usual, without causing harm or permanent damage. Deciding to do something that might mean being arrested is scary – but it feels the right thing to do. Just Stop Oil provides a lot of support for people who are able to take the risk, which means there are plenty of roles for people who can’t, such as fundraising, supporting people at police stations, and admin roles that can be done from home. Everyone can do something!”

Sue J Cook, a Councillor at Winchester City Council and Twyford Parish Council, spoke about people’s immense frustration as they tried, over 10 years, to get action on traffic blight in Twyford. You can read her short speech here.
“Now different Twyford groupings with the same overall aim are planning NVDA (non violent direct action) to highlight our problems and the urgency of addressing them. ” Cllr Sue Cook
They set up the Twyford and Colden Common Cycle Bus.
Sue invited people at the meeting to help on 1 and 8 March, when they will walk across the pelican crossing to hold up the cars and make the road safer for people to walk and cycle in support of a cycle bus for commuters from Colden Common to Hockley link 0800-1000 and 1600-1800 on those dates. See their leaflet with the “bus” timetable. What gives her hope, she was asked? “Making a difference”.

Chris Holloway, a WinACC volunteer, had looked for evidence about the value of direct action while trying to make up her mind about it. She summarised the findings of recent research into What happens when people see direct action protests on climate – summed up as “It’s complicated!” The research suggested that 2019 Extinction Rebellion mass actions were a success in raising awareness and in shifting public opinion. Some believe that it contributed to the declarations of a climate emergency by many public bodies including the UK Government, Winchester City Council and Hampshire County Council. But the research suggests that later actions have had mixed results. See the summary for the meeting. See the (short) research report in full at What happens when people see direct action protests on climate.
The meeting then saw a filmed extract of a talk from Professor Rupert Read, who was one of the founders of Extinction Rebellion. He believes that it’s now essential to get action at the middle level – between Government and the individual. This is now called the Climate Majority Project. For example, transport workers could strike for better wages and for more action on the climate. Professionals can follow the example of lawyers and doctors who have got together to press for climate action. Watch the film here. You may also want to read Rupert Read’s book (42 pages) What next on climate? The need for a new moderate flank or sign up to another of his talks here.
The aim of the WinACC meeting was to explore the ideas, not tell anyone what to do. What was very clear from everyone who spoke was that doing nothing is not an option. People need to do whatever they can to change public opinion, to influence politicians, and to stop big business, especially oil companies.
Doing nothing is not an option.
