Earth Hour is an annual event organised by WWF (the World Wide Fund for Nature, not the World Wrestling Federation, although the latter might turn out to be more fun) to raise awareness of climate change, and held this year on 30 March at 8:30pm.
The idea behind Earth Hour – an annual event dating back to 2007 – is to encourage people to switch off their lights for an hour in the evening in solidarity with their fellow citizens around the world.
So does Earth Hour really make a difference? Perhaps this question should be broadened out: how much does awareness of a problem motivate people to do something about it?
Climate change has been described as being an exceptionally fiendishly difficult issue to tackle, so much so that even if you tried to construct a similar scenario you would struggle to come up with one with a combination of societal, structural, political and psychological factors that could rival those that we are wrestling with now.
The majority of us accept that climate change is a serious problem, and yet even with decades of understanding behind us we are still struggling to fully grasp the gravity of the issue. Science now tells us that on a global basis we need to eliminate carbon dioxide emissions completely by 2050 if we are to avoid the worst impacts of climate change. If we introduce a measure of equity, i.e. allowing developing countries some slack to lift their citizens out of poverty, then the UK needs to reduce its emissions to zero by 2035.

So how have we been doing? Well, if you take into account flying, shipping and the fact that we have effectively outsourced much of our manufacturing to China and other Far Eastern countries, then UK carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions have only reduced by around 10% since 1990 – not very impressive at all. Even more worryingly, global CO2 emissions continue to rise, with seemingly the only major factor holding back even steeper rises being economic slowdown due to the global recession.
It appears then that three decades of “action” around trying to tackle carbon emissions have delivered no meaningful progress. Perhaps we should not be surprised, given the multi-faceted nature of the barriers against change; all the same, however, we face a stark choice – achieve rapid and substantial change or suffer terrible consequences in decades to come.
What can be done? In my view, switching your lights off for an hour each year is unlikely to achieve anything further in terms of raising awareness, and as with recycling there is in fact a danger is that people will feel they have “done their bit” by taking part. Instead, perhaps we should all take a long, hard look at both our own personal impact, and also what we can do to influence system change.
The scope for individual actions is, I hope, broadly understood already – for example reducing flying and eating red meat; move from driving to walking, cycling and public transport; have smaller families; and make our homes more energy-efficient. Of course, there are plenty of barriers even to changing behaviour: many of our high-carbon actions (e.g. frequent flying, big cars and bigger houses) are tied up in signalling status, and these influences are therefore particularly hard to shift, especially in our class-obsessed society. There is also a risk of the middle classes adopting eco-bling such as large, heavy electric cars and battery storage that is itself used as a type of virtue-signalling but may in reality achieve little if anything in terms of environmental and financial benefits.
Other barriers are structural – for example a lack of frequent public transport away from urban centres may make driving a necessity for some. Likewise, upgrading levels of insulation in older properties or installing renewable energy seems out of reach to many without the help of significant financial subsidy. Yet more resistance comes from habits and beliefs – if, like me, you have been eating meat for decades it can be difficult to change overnight, even if only for the difficulty of finding enough enjoyable alternatives. And the issue of whether or not to have children – or how many to have – is of course an enormously emotive and contentious issue all on its own.
And yet, change can and must happen; if we think laterally and try not to adopt an absolutist attitude then perhaps this can become easier. For example, if you decide to give up eating meat on one day a week, then the progression to doing the same on two or three nights seems much less of a challenge. Extending your mortgage to install solar panels or upgrade insulation may actually be affordable once you look at the additional monthly cost – let’s face it, around 85% of car owners have little hesitation in borrowing tens of thousands of pounds to buy a new model every three or four years, so why not take the same financial approach to making our homes more energy-efficient?
The status issue is trickier, but even here change is afoot – there are growing movements on social media for those who are giving up flying, and even this season’s Top Gear has acknowledged that big, expensive, overpowered cars are now an indulgent irrelevance. Peer pressure is likely to become the real driver of progress in this regard – voluntary actions based on conscience are only likely to get us so far in the short term. But someone still needs to jump first.
Driving change on a societal level is more of a challenge – with Brexit, the environment seems to have fallen even further down the political agenda. But it is telling to listen to MPs who say that they are rarely if ever challenged by constituents on the lack of climate change action. What happens in Westminster if we are not pushing our political representatives on this issue? The lobbyists from those with vested interests in maintaining the status quo will hold sway over a Government that does not feel that public opinion on climate change is strong enough for it to become a major policy issue. So once again, it comes back to us as individuals to start pushing this up the political agenda.
Change can take time – something we don’t have much of now, but even within this rapidly diminishing window of opportunity there is much we can all still achieve. Whether or not you take part in Earth Hour, why not put aside an hour for self-reflection to think about what is really preventing you from doing more, either in terms of effecting personal change or campaigning for action across society more broadly.
– Andy Smale – WinACC Energy Consultant and Technical Director, Expert Energy