Government abandons manifesto pledge to halt fracking

On 8 September 2022 the government issued a statement on an Energy Price Guarantee and how they were going to reform the broken energy market. It said they would “Lift the moratorium on UK shale gas production. This will enable developers to seek planning permission where there is local support, which could get gas flowing in as soon as six months.” This statement was made in spite of a pledge in the Conservative Party 2019 election manifesto that “We will not support fracking unless the science shows categorically that it can be done safely.”

WinACC’s view on fracking has not changed in the last decade ( WinACC’s 2012 technical summary ). It continues to strongly oppose the re-introduction of fracking in the UK because:

• Fracking releases natural gas (mainly methane) which is a fossil fuel and a powerful greenhouse gas. Leaks often occur during extraction and transport by pipeline. Gas combustion in domestic boilers produces carbon dioxide.
• The biggest risk from fracking is that, through methane leaks and gas combustion, it adds to the global greenhouse gas emissions that are already causing rising temperatures and dangerous changes to the global climate.
• Fracking also has associated risks to do with triggering earthquakes, high levels of water consumption and potential water pollution.
• Fracking in UK could involve drilling numerous, possibly closely-spaced, boreholes in a relatively densely populated country with the implication of round-the-clock traffic, noise and strong on-site lighting.
• It is likely to take too long for any significant amount of gas to be produced to solve short term supply problems, even in the winter of 2023-2024. “Experts say it would take years”.

Fracking involves the extraction of natural gas (methane) from deep within the Earth which is then used, primarily, to be burnt in domestic gas boilers for heating. In 2012 a report on Shale Gas Extraction published by the Royal Society concluded that regulation, especially as applied
to the integrity of wells, monitoring and the use of water, must be fit for purpose and further research was needed on the carbon footprint of shale gas.

We know the science tells us that global warming is driven by human-caused greenhouse gases accumulating in the atmosphere largely from burning fossil fuels. A 2021 IPCC report said “Meeting the long-term temperature goal in the Paris Agreement, however, implies a rapid
inflection in GHG emission trends and accelerating decline towards ‘net zero’. This is implausible without urgent and ambitious action at all scales.” The UK government signed up to the United Nations Paris Agreement in 2015, when it pledged to cut emissions by 68% by 2030, and also hosted the UN COP26 climate change meeting in Glasgow in 2021 when it signed the non-binding Glasgow Climate Pact that built on the Paris accord.

So how can the UK government now justify the re-introduction of fracking within the UK? What has changed?

The answer probably lies in the fact that there is a worldwide mismatch between the supply and demand for gas and, more recently, supplies of imported natural gas are now in jeopardy because of action by Russia. But other, more long-lasting solutions, that do not involve fracking, may simply be to greatly reduce the demand for gas by investing in retrofitting (insulating) buildings and by encouraging people to change their behaviour by, for example, turning down thermostats and dressing more appropriately indoors, and by using more, low- carbon sources of energy.

This year, 2022, is likely to go down as one in which the dangers of global warming became ever clearer both globally and in the western world. Possibly unprecedented numbers of wildfires, droughts, heat waves, melting glaciers and floods caused by heavy rainfall affected not just
parts of Africa, Asia, Latin America and the Caribbean but also North America, Australia and Europe.

In conclusion, the science advocating the alleviation of climate change by reducing the emissions of greenhouse gases from burning fossil fuels has not changed nor has the impact of highly damaging extreme weather events driven by global warming; if anything the weather impacts seem to have got worse.

Finally, we note the caveat in the government’s original statement that planning permission for fracking can be sought “where there is local support”. Given the previous negative experience of some fracking companies, for example, Cuadrilla when it tried to extract gas from the
Bowland Shale in Lancashire, local support for fracking anywhere else seems highly unlikely.

Blog written by members of the WinACC Science and Technology Advisory Panel, September 2022

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: