On 16 December 2024 the Deputy Prime Minister and Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government Angela Rayner MP published the government’s English Devolution White Paper, Power and Partnership: Foundations for Growth.
Government Plans
There are two strands: one called “Devolution”, the other “Local Government Reorganisation”.
Devolution
The White Paper says that the government wants all of England to benefit from “devolution”. This means creating Strategic Authorities, each covering a large geographical area with at least 1.5million people. Existing “Combined Authorities” and “Combined Counties” will transform into Strategic Authorities.
A strategic authority would address:
-
- Transport and local infrastructure
-
- Skills and employment support
-
- Housing and strategic planning
-
- Economic development and regeneration
-
- Environment and climate change
-
- Health, wellbeing and public service reform
-
- Public safety (page 29 of the White Paper)
The Government wants a Strategic Authority to have an elected Mayor (like London now), in which case it will be called a “Combined Mayoral Strategic Authority”. A Strategic Authority without a Mayor will be called a “Foundation Strategic Authority” and will have less benefits (page 25).
The Government will explore enabling Mayors to promote economic, social, and environmental aims and convene stakeholders with a corresponding duty on public authorities to respond.
Strategic authority areas must cover sensible economic areas e.g. travel-to-work, and enable effective delivery of key functions like Spatial Development Strategies, Local Transport Plans and Get Britain Working Plans. The Government will seek to promote alignment between devolution boundaries and other public sector boundaries.
The Government invited places to apply by 10 January 2025 to join the Devolution Priority Programme. This is for places that are able to come together under sensible geographies which meet the criteria, and where they are ready to achieve mayoral devolution at pace. This programme will aim to deliver institutions and have Mayors elected in the May 2026 elections, and provide certain places with the full backing of government to deliver to these ambitious timescales. Authorities taking part could also bid to postpone the May 2025 elections to May 2026. The Government decisions were announced on 5 February – see their update on local government reorganisation and decisions on requests to postpone local elections.
Local Government Reorganisation
The English Devolution White Paper states that the government wants all remaining two-tier areas in England to be restructured into single-tier unitary authorities.
Unitary authorities carry out all local government functions, whereas the current two-tier areas have some functions carried out by the district council (such as planning and waste collection) and some by the county council (such as education and transport).
On 5 February 2025, the Minister sent a statutory invitation to all councils in two-tier areas and small neighbouring authorities to develop proposals for unitaries. The letter sets out the criteria against which proposals will be assessed, and guidance about what proposals should include.
What size?
For most areas this will mean creating councils with a population of 500,000 or more, but there may be exceptions to ensure new structures make sense for an area, including for devolution, and decisions will be on a case-by-case basis. (p100).
Will it save money?
On the basis of international experience, it’s hard to say. Two large consultancies said it could, even allowing for the cost of the restructuring itself.
When?
The White Paper says that the government does not intend all areas to restructure at the same time, but that it “will deliver an ambitious first wave of reorganisation in this Parliament” (p101).
It typically takes two to two-and-a-half years to get from a locality submitting a proposal for unitary local government to the ‘vesting day’ of the new authority (when it formally takes on its powers).
The Secretary of State has asked councils to submit a proposal to restructure themselves into unitary authorities. BUT the final decision is made by the Secretary of State. The affected councils do not have to give formal consent.
There is no mechanism for the public to support or oppose restructuring through a petition or a referendum, even though the White Paper says that a vital element of successful devolution is the ability for local residents to engage with and hold their devolved institutions to account – and local identity plays a key role in this. (Page 31).
Implications for environment and climate change
We are disappointed how weak the White Paper is on the need for an over-arching, strategic approach to the climate emergency. It talks about specific, and useful, roles but they don’t add up to a coherent strategy:
A more detailed summary of the implications for transport from the climate perspective are in this HCAN briefing.
Click here for ideas from Hampshire Climate Action Network about how to make climate a top priority in the new local government structures.
| Sources:Local Government Association Devolution White Paper: On-the-day factual briefing 16 December 2024 https://www.local.gov.uk/parliament/briefings-and-responses/devolution-white-paper-day-factual-briefing#introduction – particularly useful sections in what the White Paper says on key issues such as transport, strategic planning, and the environment.House of Commons Library 18 Dec 2024: https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/is-my-council-going-to-be-abolished/ |
10 February 2025