This blog has been written by Bob Whitmarsh, a long standing WinACC volunteer with to share his findings from installing a heat pump at his home in Winchester. This was written following a full year of heat pump use.
His previous article, after the first six months can be found here.
Bob also made this video explening what he did to his home in Winchester, helped by WinACC’s superhomes project:

An air-source heat pump was installed in early September 2022 at our detached 4-bedroom house in Winchester. An earlier blog related our experience of the installation and how the heat pump performed during the first six months, including the winter of 2022-2023. In this blog I want to tell readers about how the heat pump has compared over a whole 12-month cycle with previous years when our house was heated by a condensing gas boiler.
Energy monitoring before the heat pump
For years before our heat pump was installed I had been recording gas and electricity meter readings twice a month. In addition, we had long had a solar thermal panel which generates hot water mainly in the summer months. Gas had been used for central heating, hot water (showers and washing up) and cooking on gas rings. Electricity had covered lighting, appliances (IT equipment, TV, washing machine etc.), an oven and the pumps for the central heating and solar thermal system.
Energy monitoring after the heat pump
I continued to regularly monitor the gas and electricity meters, including a new heat-pump-only meter, after the heat pump was installed but, in addition, I was able to download half-hourly electricity consumption data from LOOP. This is a wonderful online resource available to anyone with a smart meter. Because of the way in which the set points of our room thermostat are programmed on a daily basis I was able to use the LOOP data and the heat pump meter to separate out the electricity used for general requirements (such as lighting, appliances, the oven and solar pump), central heating and hot water.
How well should a heat pump perform?
The normal metric for calculating the performance of a heat pump is the Seasonal Coefficient of Performance (SCoP) which compares the heat delivered against the electrical energy used over a 12-month period. However, in practice, installed heat pumps do not routinely provide the facility to measure the SCoP. The UK average CoP (measured over less than a year?) for installed air source heat pumps is reported to be 2.5 (1), when the outside temperature is between -10 and 5 °C, whereas our installer, perhaps optimistically, had predicted a SCoP of 3.3.
A comparison of energy consumed before and after the heat pump installation
A different approach, which I used, was to directly compare the gas consumed for central heating before the heat pump was installed with the post-heat pump electricity consumed for heating (see graph). After the heat pump was installed, I found that we used 2.5 times less energy for heating between October 2022 and March 2023 compared to the average of the gas used for heating in the previous 5 years. However, this figure is approximate because it takes no account of a) a likely change to the hot water demand after the heat pump was installed (we had installed a higher pressure shower), b) a lower hot water thermostat setting (it had been lowered from 55 °C to 50 °C) and c) increased loft insulation (from 270mm to 400mm) let alone the possible impact of a warming climate since 2017.

Graph showing the estimated cumulative energy used monthly for central heating over 12 months both before (2017-2021 average) and after (October 2022 – September 2023) the installation of our heat pump (HP) (2). On the x-axis 1=January, 2=February etc. Note the very low consumption, when heating was mostly not required, from April to September.
Costs and the carbon footprint
Unfortunately, our heat pump, which uses around 2.5 times less energy than a gas boiler, is not cheaper to run under present circumstances. The reason is that currently the price per kWh that I pay a well known energy company for electricity is 3.8 times greater than the price of gas! This means that, using my estimate, our heating bills are expected be greater by the ratio 3.8/2.5 or 52% higher. Even our installer predicted we would see a 10% increase in post-heat pump heating costs.
In fact, compared with 14 EU countries, the UK (and Germany) have the highest electricity to gas price ratios. (3) The other countries have price ratios of 3 or less, but mostly more than 2, which makes installing a heat pump much more attractive there. Hopefully the UK government will soon come to realise that if there is to be a large-scale move away from gas boilers to heat pumps then (low-carbon) electricity has to become much cheaper relative to fossil fuel natural gas. (4)
Nevertheless, one huge and immediate consolation is that not only do we now use around 2.5 times less energy for central heating than previously but also that we are no longer dependent on fossil fuels, even indirectly, because we buy very low-carbon electricity from renewable sources and so the carbon footprint from heating our house is now a small fraction of what it was previously.
p.s. for anyone interested in reading more about heat pumps a good place to start is here .
Bob Whitmarsh
WinACC Volunteer, October 2023
(1) Gibb, Duncan, Rosenow, Jan, Lowes, Richard, and Hewitt, Neil J. “Coming in from the Cold: Heat Pump Efficiency at Low Temperatures.” Joule 7 (September 20, 2023): 1–4.
(2) Estimated gas consumption is average monthly gas consumption less average monthly cooking consumption and less average monthly domestic hot water consumption in 2022-2023). Averages determined over 2017-2021. Estimated monthly electricity consumption is from monthly air-source heat pump meter readings less monthly hot water consumption (from LOOP data).
(3) https://www.gov.uk/government/statistical-data-sets/international-domestic-energy-prices
(4) There are signs that government already realises the problem. The Daily Telegraph reported on 3 October 2023 that a government minister has said that “Household gas bills could rise under plans to boost the roll-out of heat pumps across the UK”. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2023/10/03/household-gas-bills-expected-rise-under-heat-pump-rollout/