Positive Tipping Points webinar summary

WinACC is a member of the Positive Tipping Points Community of Practice based in the University of Exeter. Consequently, it is actively involved in research into Positive Tipping Points. The concept of positive tipping points and how they may influence what WinACC does in future were explained in the following two short talks.

Peter Lefort, from the University of Exeter, opened the webinar by defining a tipping point. A tipping point occurs when a system changes rapidly, and invariably irretrievably, from one state to another. A system can exhibit a characteristic S-shaped graph, for example when its growth is plotted against time. An example might be the adoption of a new technology in the home. Alternatively, it can be thought that as a system is pushed up a slope it is subject to resistance but then suddenly it reaches a tipping point at the top and gains momentum as its rapidly descends to a new state.

For many people, in the context of climate change, a tipping point has a negative connotation in the sense that passing it is expected to lead to a more dangerous future and away from an irretrievable past. But Peter’s point was that some tipping points can be positive and can lead to a better future. Even though we as individuals can have little influence on an outcome basically all our contribution will add up. He gave the examples of buying peat-free compost and adopting plant-based diets.

There are three situations that if they exist together usually lead to a tipping point: 1) the conditions are right for change, 2) there are reinforcing feedbacks and 3) something happens to trigger the change. Many factors, such as affordability, a critical mass of people, the influence of social networks and innovation, can contribute to each situation. However, one problem is how to recognise an approaching tipping point.

Jo Crocker, WinACC’s Executive Director, then took over and explained how WinACC was trying to adopt the idea of positive tipping points in its work to mitigate the climate crisis. She felt that WinACC was trying to navigate a path between resistance to change and achieving an increase in momentum towards a new and safer state of the world. Although it was very hard to measure WinACC’s impact it was necessary to persevere. For example, the WeCAN climate action network was working with local groups helping them to develop the leverage they could exert to accomplish change. It was important to recognise that different actors can contribute in different ways. There was no single solution that WinACC should adopt.

Finally, Peter introduced an exercise in asking the webinar participants to suggest the likely impacts of installing solar panels on the roof of a community building.

Participants were generally very positive in their response to the webinar commenting that the discussion was “uplifting”; and “morale boosting”. Several said that it helped them to carry on and persevere in what they were doing to mitigate global heating. Even though climbing the slope to a (positive) tipping point could involve backsliding it was encouraging to be told that the world can sometimes react positively in a non-linear way.

Further reading here.

Bob Whitmarsh – WinACC volunteer

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: