Application Approved: 19/5/2021
******
This summary was prepared to offer assistance for responses to this specific planning application. The deadline for comments has now passed. WinACC’s response is reproduced below. You’ll find more general comments in WinACC’s overview of Solar Farms.
To visit the site, a good access point (with parking) is from Christmas Hill, adjacent to the water tower. The byway takes you across the A34 and along the northern perimeter of the site. (this higher resolution map is published by the City Council)

About the Solar Farm
Capacity: 25 MW Land area: 42 hectares (104 acres)
Battery Storage: in addition to generating electricity, it will be possible to store renewable energy for release into the Grid as required
Impact: elimination of approximately 11,180t3 of CO2 emissions annually. Source: Pegasus Group Planning Statement
Duration: 35 years, after which the site can be cleared and restored to full agricultural use.
About the Planning Application
Expiry Date for Comments: 2nd December 2020
Winchester City Council Planning Ref: 20/02311/FUL
Location: between the A272 and A34 to the north-west of Winchester
Parish: Headbourne Worthy
Applicant: Enviromena Asset Management UK Ltd
Planning agent: Pegasus Group
Community Engagement
The Planning Agent was invited by Headbourne Worthy Parish Council and South Wonston Parish Council to speak at their meetings in November 2020 to discuss the proposals and answer any questions.
This FAQs document was prepared by the Planning Agent as an alternative to a normal consultation event which was not possible due to the Covid-19 pandemic.
Headbourne Worthy Parish Council has published more useful documents about the proposals (scroll down the page)
WinACC Response
This is WinACC’s response to the application. You can contact us at renewables@winacc.org.uk.
******
This location appears to be ideal for a solar farm. Wedged into the V-intersection of two A-roads, the site is largely screened from surrounding viewpoints, both adjacent and distant. For example, long sections of the northern and eastern boundaries are screened by embankments.
Moreover, the amenity of the public rights of way, both within and around the site, is diminished by noise pollution from one of the most intensively busy stretches of the A34.
Regarding the Scheduled Monument, Worthy Down Ditch, we note that the applicant’s Heritage Statement proposes a 10m buffer zone to ensure that any harm to the setting of the Monument is less than substantial.
In criticising this measure as inadequate, the Historic England submission overlooks the provision to clear the site after the 35-year lifespan of the development. Any harm to the setting of the Scheduled Monument is therefore temporary.
This single renewable energy development would deliver output equating to more than 2.5% of our District’s total consumption of electricity. That represents a significant response to the climate emergency in our District, funded entirely by private finance. In our view, such a clear public benefit outweighs any less than substantial (and temporary) harm to the setting of the Monument, a material consideration (para 196 of NPPF 2019).
We note that Headbourne Worthy Parish Council has expressed support for the application. We welcome the applicant’s consultation with the Parish Council and that information about the solar farm has been posted on the Council’s website.
Good sites for solar farms are few and far between; rarer still is a suitable site within 5km of the centre of the City of Winchester, where a significant share of our District’s consumption of electricity originates. This application is therefore a strong candidate to make up for lost time since our most recent large scale renewable energy development, way back in 2017.
WinACC strongly supports this planning application.
How to Comment on a Planning Application
- Go to the City Council’s Planning home page and Log In (Register first, if you haven’t already done so)
- Enter the Planning Reference Number (20/02311/FUL) in the search box.
- Click on Comments, and post your comment in the text box as directed
Technical Assessments
These statements are copied, without amendment, from background papers and consultee comments that will be considered by the planning officers. The relevant document is identified in italics. These extracts have been drawn from hundreds of pages of reports and are not presented as a substitute for them.
Visual Impact
The site boundaries –A34 and A272 are vegetated which does provide natural screening of the site. Views from the northern boundary, a public right of way, is primarily screened by trees and scrub. (WCC Landscape)
Given the scale of the proposed solar PV development, the extent of visibility beyond the site boundaries is remarkably small.
The proposed solar arrays within Zone A would be set back from the sunken track (the byway running along the northern boundary of the site) to ensure they are not visible from the PROW (public right of way)
The proposed solar panels would inevitably be visible at close proximity from bridleway no. 4 between the A272, Worthy Grove and Little Grove …… However, the physical alignment of the bridleway would be retained and the solar panels and security (deer) fencing would be set back from the PROW. (Landscape and Visual Impact)
We request that consideration is given to screening planting along the western fence to provide a green corridor for bridleway users (bridleway no. 4). (Hampshire Countryside Services)
Agriculture
81.1% of the Application Site is Grade 3a ‘Good Quality’ Agricultural Land, alongside 10.8% which is Grade 2 ‘Very Good Quality’ Agricultural Land. (Agricultural Land Classification)
The results of the Sequential Analysis Study demonstrate that there are no alternative areas of land which are of a lower agricultural land grade, which are an available and deliverable alternative to the Application Site. (Sequential Analysis Study)
Biodiversity
The proposals would inevitably result in the removal of the arable cereal crop and replacement with chalk grassland that would be managed to encourage wildflowers and species diversity. With a medium sensitivity and a high magnitude of change, the proposals would result in a major beneficial effect on the chalk grassland within the site. (Landscape and Visual Impact)
There is no requirement to remove any high-quality or individually surveyed trees in order to implement the proposed development. (Arboricultural Impact Assessment)
Additional bird nesting provision will be made through the inclusion of six bird boxes erected on suitably-sized trees located at the peripheries of the Site.
The base security fence will be lifted in places to allow the free movement of wildlife, including brown hare (known to be present) through the grassland habitats. (Biodiversity Management Plan)
The proposed development will result in a clear biodiversity net gain of over 10% Habitat Units and 6% Hedgerow Units…..delivered through species diverse chalk grassland and wildflower seeding, 160m of hedgerow planting and additional hazel scrub underplanting.
Trees, woodland and hedgerows will be retained and protected during development and suitable buffer zones will be established to achieve this, hence there are no likely effect on breeding bird species. (Ecological Assessment)
Heritage
The Scheduled Monument of the Bronze Age ‘ranch boundary’ known as Worthy Down Ditch lies within the eastern part of the site……A 10m-wide development exclusion zone…….has been incorporated within the proposed solar farm layout in order to minimise harm to the significance of the Scheduled Monument. (Heritage Statement)
We would recommend that a full assessment of setting and impact of the proposed development on the monument (Worthy Down Ditch) is undertaken. We would view this as being proportionate in light of the asset’s status as a Scheduled Monument. (Historic England)
Join Us?
If you feel you can make a contribution to our solar farm campaign and other energy projects, please consider joining our Renewable Energy Action Group.
We especially welcome knowledge and skills as follows:
- Technical, commercial and local planning experience of renewable technologies at small/medium scale, especially solar
- GIS software skills relevant to local area energy planning
- Event delivery and marketing
- Current and ex-parish councillors or community leaders in a position to help WinACC reach local communities for engagement with energy projects
Meetings are held every other month in Winchester, or virtually, usually on Monday evenings. Contact renewables@winacc.org.uk.