Over the last decade, homeowners have increasingly had opportunities to join the renewable energy revolution, thanks in large part to financial support from the government.
Probably the most successful technology in this regard is solar photovoltaics (solar PV) – solar panels that generate electricity during daylight hours.
In 2010, the government introduced the Feed-in Tariff (FiT) – a financial subsidy aimed at encouraging the installation of renewable electricity generation. The subsidy was initially set at a very generous level and financially savvy people quickly picked up on as a great long-term investment opportunity. As well as spurring thousands of homeowners into installing systems, businesses saw an opportunity to make money with “free solar panels“ schemes targeting households who could not afford to buy the systems outright.
The take-up for the subsidy became so popular that it caught the government out, using up their budget for renewable electricity generation much faster than they had anticipated. As a result, in 2011 the government were forced to slash the FiT rates for solar PV by around 50%, and in subsequent years further cuts were introduced on the basis that the wholesale cost of solar PV technology was dropping rapidly.
In 2018, a final consultation on the future of FiT resulted in a decision to remove the Feed-in Tariff subsidy entirely for new installations from 1 April 2019. Fortunately, the government has acknowledged that it is unreasonable to expect solar PV owners to give away their unused power free of charge, and there is currently discussion around the possibility of retaining an export payment. Any export tariff will be paid to system owners for every unit of electricity generated that they don’t use themselves – it is likely to link to the latest generation of smart meters that can measure and record power flowing in the reverse direction, unlike older meters which simply acknowledged a backflow or even (if you were lucky!) ran backwards.

So where does this leave people considering installing solar PV from April – is it still worth doing?
From a financial perspective, a solar PV system will certainly become a long-term investment. Even at the current level of subsidy, payback times of 15-20 years are typical. Once the FiT disappears, for a typical 4kW system an owner will be looking at savings of £100-£200 a year on energy bills, and typically £100 for the export tariff if the current rate is retained. Given that the full cost of installing a 4kW system is around £6000 at present, one is looking at a payback of well over 20 years. The best returns are for those with unshaded south-facing roofspaces, and who tend to be in during the day to make the most of the power generated.
Even for people like me who work from home, much of the electricity generated by a typical solar PV system is not used when it is generated, especially in the summer. Electrical demand is usually highest in the early mornings and evenings when generation is low; when generation is at its peak in the middle of the day, families are often at work or school/college and demand is low. Although the energy is never wasted (it is simply exported to the National Grid for someone else to use) it is, in a sense, a shame for the system owner not to be able to take full advantage of it.
There are a couple of solutions to this problem, the first being battery storage. Batteries can soak up the excess generation, releasing the energy later in the day when the sun has set and everyone’s home and switching appliances on again. This arrangement also has benefits for the National Grid as it reduces the strain on the system at peak times. Unfortunately, batteries at present are very expensive and with savings of £100-£150 a year are unlikely to pay for themselves in energy savings over their lifetime. In addition, due in part to the energy-intensive manufacturing process, the environmental benefits of battery storage are marginal at the moment, although some systems use batteries recycled from electric vehicles. In time, however, system prices will come down and batteries may become cost-effective.
A second solution is available for people with a hot water cylinder that has (or can be fitted with) an electrical immersion element. A number of companies market a fancy bit of electronic kit that detects when there is excess solar PV generation and diverts it to the immersion element, using that power to heat your hot water cylinder. Payback times are likely to be in the region of ten years or so, although this could vary considerably depending on the installation cost and patterns of use. We hope to look at these energy storage solutions in more detail in a later blog article.
Of course, the decision to install solar PV shouldn’t be all about money; the environmental benefits are clearly – and increasingly – important. A 4kW 16-panel system would generate somewhere around 3500kWh each year, which is as much electricity as a typical 3-bedroom household would use in that time. The Energy Saving Trust estimates a carbon saving of 1.3-1.6 tonnes per annum on this basis, which is roughly equivalent to the carbon emissions of an average driver in the UK. My own 4kW system is split between each side of my roof, facing east and west, but still generates around twice as much electricity as I use in the house over the course of a year, showing that even sub-optimal systems can be very effective.
Overall, for those happy to live with a longer financial payback, solar PV is still one of the most effective ways to reduce your carbon footprint, especially once you have already tackled improvements to energy efficiency and conservation in areas such as heating, insulation and lighting.
For more information about solar PV, visit the Energy Saving Trust website
– Andy Smale – WinACC Energy Consultant and Technical Director, Expert Energy