Too little too late to justify airport expansion
The government recently announced its plan to increase flights from Heathrow by building a new runway. The Chancellor of the Exchequer, Rachel Reeves, justified any resulting environmental impact on the grounds that “Sustainable Aviation Fuel [SAF] reduces CO2 [carbon dioxide*] emissions compared to fossil jet fuel by around 70%”.
Yet projections suggest that the UK’s Sustainable Aviation Fuel production will reach only around 10% of the UK’s current annual demand for jet fuel by 2030. Perhaps even more alarming is that some American companies are designing and testing new supersonic aircraft which typically burn 4 to 10 times more fuel per passenger while saving just three hours on a flight from London to New York.
Although Sustainable Aviation Fuels can indeed be produced today in relatively small quantities they are far from having zero lifetime emissions.
This article explains why Sustainable Aviation Fuels are unlikely to be able to meet demand in the near future.
A WinACC report on Sustainable Aviation Fuels can be found here.
Climate impact of burning aviation fuels
Aviation causes 2.5% of global carbon dioxide emissions today but the warming effect is significantly increased in the short term by other gases released at high altitude, especially water vapour. At the same time the airline industry expects flying to more than double by 2045.
Why Sustainable Aviation Fuels?
Although both electric and hydrogen aircraft may be used for short flights, they are unsuitable for long flights due to weight and space issues. Therefore, attention is being focussed on ‘Sustainable Aviation Fuels’ (SAFs) that can eventually entirely replace the kerosene used in existing aircraft but are derived from non-fossil fuel sources.
Sustainable Aviation Fuels are attractive for the airline industry because they can be used in existing aircraft (which have long lifetimes) and do not require significant new infrastructure and regulation. Sustainable Aviation Fuels can be either blended with or replace current jet fuels depending on composition, the aircraft design and availability.
Making Sustainable Aviation Fuel
There are many ways to make Sustainable Aviation Fuels. Today’s Sustainable Aviation Fuels are mainly derived from biomass (plant material) including waste cooking oil etc. However, processes are also being developed to produce Sustainable Aviation Fuels from ‘green’ hydrogen produced from water using renewable electricity, or syngas (a mixture of hydrogen and carbon monoxide) produced from water and carbon dioxide from the air with heat from a solar power tower.
These sources produce intermediate fuels such as syngas which are processed in a separate step to make them sufficiently similar to kerosene.
Limited potential
The reason Sustainable Aviation Fuel supply is expected to be limited is that the energy sources they are produced from and the infrastructure capacity to produce Sustainable Aviation Fuels from them are severely limited. For example, the UK does not regard producing fuel from crops as sustainable. The huge DRAX power station struggles to find enough biomass to burn with controversy surrounding the sustainability of its burning of trees from American forests. Renewable electricity is not close to even supplying the UK’s domestic needs today and producing hydrogen from it incurs a severe energy penalty and cost. Solar ovens for creating Sustainable Aviation Fuels may eventually be built at scale, but they are currently in the early stages of development.
In addition to the expected slow ramp-up in its production Sustainable Aviation Fuel suffers from other drawbacks. It also doesn’t mitigate the non-carbon (albeit less long-lasting) warming impacts of existing fuels such as the release of water vapour. One major issue is that Sustainable Aviation Fuels are currently significantly more expensive than existing fossil-based fuels due to the cost and energy losses of the production processes.
What now?
Without access to very low carbon aviation fuels in sufficient quantities the world is not going to meet internationally agreed targets for global temperatures and a net zero society. It may take a decade or more for the most promising Sustainable Aviation Fuels to meet the demand for fuels at scale.
The only alternative appears to be a dramatic and timely decrease in the number of flights in the next ten or more years.
Some other sources of information about Sustainable Aviation Fuels:
The trouble with SAF | Flight Free UK
2021 series: Can we fly carbon neutral? | The Flight Free Podcast
Bob Whitmarsh March 2025 (with input from Brian Shorter and Robin Speed)
Carbon dioxide* is a harmful greenhouse gas, greenhouse gases are the polluting gases that cause climate change.