This blog was written for WinACC by Brian Shorter, one of the volunteers on our Scientific and Technical Advisory Panel.
Cruise Ship Holidays
Cruise holidays are becoming increasingly popular; and indeed yearly passenger numbers, worldwide, are estimated to have increased from 18 million in 2010 to 32 million in 2024. Amazingly, there are said to be 370 cruise ships in the world at the moment, with more and bigger ones being built. As a result, some cruise holidays are now cheaper than land based ones.
Some of the issues
For some cruise ports, the ships are controversial. They bring large numbers of visitors, sometimes known as “hit and run” tourists, who mostly spend little money, and make for crowded streets. This blog, though, is about physical environmental issues.
Most of us now realise that flying produces high emissions that makes climate change more serious; and hopefully consider this in making travel plans, for whatever purpose. So surely keeping out of the air must be better? Well, not necessarily. If you watch this film ‘How cruise ships became a catastrophe for the planet’, you will understand some of the issues.
Just think of some of the large cruise ships that you have seen pictured, or even been on. Many carry thousands of passengers, with swimming pools, water slides, gyms, stages, and multiple restaurants and bars. Think about the amount of energy required for all this, as well as for the air conditioning. On almost all ships this is made by burning oil. Think of the waste produced – water, food, “stuff”, and, last but far from least, the waste products in the air from burning all that oil. And of course there are massive engines to drive the ship.
Estimates of the greenhouse gas, and other emissions from cruise ships vary, but one study by the International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) estimates that emissions from a cruise ship holiday are more than double those from flying the same distance to a resort and staying at a hotel there ‘what if I told you that cruising is worse for the planet than flying?’. It is estimated that 30 – 40% of the ship’s energy is required for the hotel/entertainment operations ‘can you take a clean cruise holiday?’. On land much of this energy would be produced by renewables, nuclear or gas, rather than the far more polluting oil used on a ship.
The cruise industry is aware of significant greenhouse gas emissions, and many newer ships are now designed to run on liquid natural gas (LNG). This results in lower emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2), the major greenhouse gas. However, many scientists think that the leakage of methane – the major constituent of LNG, and a much more powerful greenhouse gas than CO2 – results in a bigger climate change impact than just using oil ‘the climate impact of using LNG as a marine fuel’. In fact it is estimated that cruise ships pumped out 17% more carbon dioxide in 2022 than they did in 2019, according to a Transport & Environment study, while methane emissions rose 500% over the same period.
What sort of impacts does all this result in?
At sea, as well as the greenhouse gases alluded to above, high amounts of sulphur gases and other gases are emitted. Sulphur oxides (SOx) are particularly bad for human health, and are a serious issue when a ship is in port. In 2022, Europe’s 218 cruise ships emitted four times as much SOx as all the continent’s cars ‘how luxury cruises are polluting Europe’s cities (PDF)’. However, the use of LNG emits almost no SOx.
It is estimated that 25% of ocean waste comes from cruise ships; though this does include grey water and treated (to varying levels) sewage.
In port, where cruise ships spend a lot of time, electricity is obviously still required. Some ports and some ships, in increasing numbers, have the infrastructure to “plug in” to the port’s power system. However, despite this, in 2022, in one of the busiest European cruise ports, Barcelona, cruise ships produced nearly three times more SOx than all the cars and light vehicles in the city. For Southampton, a less busy cruise port, that ratio was over eight! Interestingly, European cars have SOx limits 100 times stricter than ships ‘Barecelona was the dirtiest cruise port in Europe last year (2023)’.
What can be done?
As mentioned above, the transfer to LNG as a fuel might be helping to mitigate some forms of pollution; but many think it has a negative impact on greenhouse gas reduction.
Ships could be designed to run on green methanol, a low emission fuel, but the required quantities are not being produced at present. Battery ships are not currently viable for long distances, but for those staying close to shore, such as the Norwegian Hurtigruten ships, it could be an option. In fact, Hurtigruten are now designing a wind, solar and shore charged battery powered ship ‘an energy efficient cruise ship’.
It could be mandatory for those ships that have the capability to “plug in” at the port to do so, where possible.
All emissions could be reduced by reducing speed.
Total emissions could be reduced by a reduction in demand; or perhaps by supply, by making regulations far stricter, thus affecting the cost of cruising.
If you do choose to go on a cruise….
….then look at this 2024 Cruise Ship Report Card produced by Friends of the Earth. This scores 21 cruise ship companies according to four environmental factors, and ranks them from B (Hurtigruten, HX Hurtigruten Expeditions and Disney Cruises Line) to F (Seabourn Cruises, Cunard, Carnival Cruise Line, P & O Cruises and Costa Cruises). So perhaps think a little more carefully before you go now.
Brian Shorter, STAP member