WinACC is astonished and deeply concerned that a proposal to reopen an oil well near Winchester has been approved. It appears that short-term commercial profit is being put before a significant contribution to global heating without any consideration for the local communities let alone the rest of the world.
Global heating is a real and serious problem. In Britain, only 4% of people are not concerned by it. Our warming world is driven by greenhouse gases accumulating in the atmosphere. The more gas that accumulates the hotter the world becomes. Burning fossil fuels, whether for cars, planes, heating homes or to generate electricity, releases carbon dioxide, the most common greenhouse gas.
Scientists warned eight years ago that to keep within the Paris Agreement’s target of 1.5°C (or even 2.0°C) of dangerous warming humanity must stop extracting fossil fuels such as oil, gas and coal.
We can already see the impact of just 1.2°C of global warming today in the increasing frequency and severity of extreme weather events such as heatwaves, wildfires, droughts, and flash floods. Many of these events are much more likely to have happened because of global heating. Plus, as glaciers melt and the oceans warm, sea-level is rising. World Weather Attribution (Imperial College, London) have said that without human induced climate change recent heat events would have been extremely rare. In China it would have been about a 1 in 250-year event while maximum heat like in July 2023 would have been virtually impossible to occur in the US/Mexico region and Southern Europe if humans had not warmed the planet by burning fossil fuels.
In light of the above, Winchester Action on the Climate Crisis (WinACC) is alarmed to learn that the Star Energy Group (formerly IGas Energy) proposes, on behalf of a consortium, to re-open an oil well known as Avington 3 in the Matterley Farm Estate near Cheesefoot Head, Winchester which was last active in 2018. On 13 July 2023 it was announced that the Avington Joint Operating Committee has now formally agreed to restart oil production at the field. The company has been given permission, after appealing against an initial rejection, to pump oil from the well until December 2026 (further details about the planning process are below). Not only will economically insignificant amounts of oil be produced but the greenhouse gas methane, the principal component of natural gas, previously encountered in this oil field, will also escape to the atmosphere.
By weight, methane has a warming impact 84 times greater than that of carbon dioxide over 20 years. It is for this reason that an amendment to the Energy Bill, currently going through parliament, has been proposed to make the burning (flaring) and release (venting) of natural gas illegal by the end of 2024. This was supported by a number of organisations including WinACC and CPRE. By weight, flaring produces almost three times as much carbon dioxide as the methane being burnt whereas venting alone releases the equivalent of 84 times more carbon dioxide.
WinACC is pleased to note that Winchester City Council recently passed a motion stating that it is opposed to the extraction of oil and gas. Hampshire County Council, on the other hand, in their draft partial update of the Minerals and Waste Plan supports further oil and gas development.
Some questions and answers
This section will be updated as we discover more information.
Q. Where exactly is the oil well situated?
A: The well is situated at grid reference 453914, 128375 within the Matterley Farm Estate between the A31 and the A272 (see map from South Downs National Park Authority). You can view it on Google Maps here.
Q. Why have I never heard of this before?
A: We believe that this proposal has received minimal scrutiny by the public due to the rural nature of the site and the completion of the 2020 round of planning largely during the first Covid lockdown. No public submissions were made, suggesting awareness was low.
The planning application for an appraisal licence for this well was submitted to the South Downs National Park Authority on the 18th March 2020. A notice was put up on the 14th March at a location close to the site, three neighbours were informed and a planning notice was published in The Hampshire Independent’s 10th April edition. Whilst this was circulated in hard copy the circulation was substantially curtailed by a lack of delivery people. The publisher suggests it may have been approximately 10% of normal levels.
Two of the local parish councils were aware. Itchen Valley PC discussed the application in their meeting on the 23rd April 2020 and chose to support it. Itchen Stoke & Ovington Parish Council were made aware by the land owner who sits on the council. During their meeting on the 19th February 2020, after declaring an interest, he ‘advised he had been approached by an Oil/Gas Company Director looking to discuss temporary permission to explore oil extraction in the Parish’. The chair of the parish council and another councillor undertook to meet the company. We do not have details of this meeting at this time. Reference to this meeting was made in the planning application and the chair submitted a written comment in support of the application. In this comment they clarify that the oil well is not within the parish and write that ‘Councillors are clear that most local inhabitants are unaware of the wellsite’.
The application was refused and later appealed by the applicant in 2021. However, only neighbours and consultees are notified about appeals.
Q. On what grounds did the South Downs National Park Planning Authority refuse permission?
A: The full text from the decision letter for SDNP/20/01255/CM is most helpful here:
“The proposal constitutes new mineral development that fails to conserve and enhance the National Park and it would create an unwelcome precedent for further oil and gas development within the National Park. The applicant has failed to adequately assess the cost of or scope for oil extraction outside of the National Park. The applicant has also failed to adequately assess the impact of the proposal on the environment, landscape and recreational opportunities and has failed to propose suitable mitigation measures to conserve and enhance the National Park. The development has not therefore proven to be demonstrably in the public interest or exhibit exceptional circumstances and would be in conflict with policies SD1, SD2, SD4 and SD9 of the South Downs Local Plan 2019, policies 4 and 24 of the Hampshire Minerals and Waste Plan (2013) and the National Planning Guidance contained in the National Planning Policy Framework 2019.”
Q. How did the planners grant permission for the oil well to be reopened when permission was initially refused?
A: The full appeal decision on 10 December 2021 can be accessed online on the planning inspectorate’s website.
The decision hinges around detail within the Hampshire CC Minerals and Waste plan 2013. This has provisions to limit major minerals development within the National Park aside from in exceptional circumstances. But, the development was determined not to constitute a ‘major minerals development’ based on definitions within the National Planning Framework and so these conditions were not applied. This meant that the SDNPA’s approach to whether exceptional circumstances were met or not did not apply. The applicant’s planning statement had also included detail on this point of policy, but again this was not found to be relevant.
The Planning Inspectorate also gave weight to a contribution towards energy security, benefits to the economy, and determined there was limited impact to the environment and recreational opportunity based on the evidence presented to them.
WinACC considers that it is notable that in no part of the planning process is climate or global heating mentioned. There was no attempt to consider how the project sits within national or regional carbon budgets.
Whilst the controls on environmental impact were found to be acceptable by the Planning Inspectorate, there is reference to a SNDPA potential enforcement action in the Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment that we have not yet managed to access. There are also currently no details in the public domain regarding the conditions relating to the Oil and Gas Authority (OGA) licensing of this operation or the ongoing monitoring by the Environment Agency. This makes it difficult to adequately scrutinise activity at the site.
The arguments surrounding economic benefit carried substantial weight within the Planning Inspectorate decision but in the applicant’s planning statement there are no specifics about the economic benefits and no details about how the development will benefit the local economy. Reference is made to unspecified previous proposals made by IGas within the National Park.
Q: How much oil is Star Energy expecting to recover at Avington?
A: Previous drilling which stopped in 2017 recovered about 336 barrels of oil a day. This data comes from their reported figures which are publicly available on the NSTA database. Each barrel is about 159 litres of oil and when burnt will generate approximately 433 kg of carbon dioxide. So in total this well will cause the emissions of about 53 kt (kilotonnes) of carbon dioxide each year.
This figure is comparable to the emissions in Winchester district in 2021 from either domestic electricity consumption or a third of all motorway traffic or would wipe out by a 20% margin the net gains (negative emissions) from land use and forestry. For comparison Winchester District’s total emissions of carbon dioxide in 2021 were in the region of 720 kt.
Q: I know that methane is a significant greenhouse gas that is often present along with oil as ‘associated gas’. Do we know how much methane might be released from this and similar drilling operations in Southern England?
A: Well operators report the amount of gas (mainly methane) recovered alongside data on oil recovery on the NSTA database. This data does not include any leaks of methane that aren’t captured along with oil, water etc that come directly up the well shaft.
The Clean Air Task Force (CATF) has produced significant evidence of venting and leaks from onshore oil and gas facilities in the UK using a specialised infrared camera, as reported by DrillOrDrop.
For example, this report highlighted significant venting of methane by Perenco at their Kimmeridge site in Dorset. When challenged, Perenco undertook to start capturing and selling the methane by 2022. However, from the reported data (below) this has not yet happened, although the reported data shows there was brief episode of flaring in 2022, although venting seems now to have resumed at the same level as before as show in the NSTA data.
Figure 1. Gas venting and flaring activity at Kimmeridge. Units are MMscf – million standard cubic feet – per month. Source NSTA.
It should be stressed that this activity is all legal – these emissions are reported in the national atmospheric emissions inventory (NAEI) and reported as part of national greenhouse gas emissions – for example 334 t (tonnes) of methane were reported from drilling at Kimmeridge for the year 2021.
At the Avington site, historically reported methane emissions are much lower (see below) probably amounting to less than 1 tonne of methane per year. WinCC is actively seeking further details about the monitoring of the site from the Environment Agency.
Q: How can we measure the methane emissions at these sites?
A: The CATF data (see previous question), which is produced using an infra-red camera, can show where there are significant methane emissions not captured by official monitoring but currently can’t give an accurate quantitative value. Generally measuring methane emissions is a complex and evolving area. It is hoped that newer satellites will start to provide useful data.
Figure 2. Gas venting data reported for the Avington site. Units MMscf – million standard cubic feet (per month).
Q: I know that there has been controversy due to oil and gas companies ‘flaring’ natural gas rather than capturing it so it can be used. How bad is flaring?
A: Huge amounts of valuable natural gas have been wasted, for example in fracking in the USA. However, compared with venting – where gas is simply released to the atmosphere – flaring is vastly preferable because the resulting release of carbon dioxide has between about 8 and 30 times (depending on the time frame) lower warming effect than the original methane.
Methane previously recovered at the Avington site was vented as shown in the plot above and there is no evidence that, as sometimes happens, methane was used on site to generate electricity.
Q: Does the drilling present other risks to the local environment?
A: Yes, and this was one of the reasons for the application being rejected by planners in 2020. See the Question above which gives the grounds for the South Downs National Park Planning Authority refusal of permission. We don’t really know the full impacts though. One risk relates to the large amounts of water (much more than the oil recovered) which are recovered along with the oil which has to be stored and removed to another site in tankers. Presumably this water could contain pollutants. Clearly the operator has taken what they believe to be appropriate precautions such as building a bund (low bank) around the site perimeter.
Ways to join in
Get an overview of the campaign here.
Support this campaign
We’re working hard behind the scenes to kickstart a campaign against this pumping of oil. If you’d like to hear more about what we’re up to and volunteer your time, we’d love to hear from you. Please fill in the google form and we’ll get in touch when we have firmed up our plans.
Sign up to receive our newsletter
Packed full of ways to take action, campaigns to support, projects to participate in and events to attend. Subscribing to our e-newsletter is the easiest way to join in and keep up to date with Winchester Action on the Climate Crisis.
Just scroll down to the footer of this page to find the ‘subscribe’ button.
Donate to WinACC
Projects and campaigns to fight the climate crisis don’t happen by magic. Without donations we wouldn’t be here, most grants don’t cover running costs such as insurance, zoom subscriptions etc. If you can help, a one off or regular donation would be very welcome.