Paper written by David Ball
March 2020
This paper considers the impact of electricity generated using local renewable energy on the local carbon footprint, in particular for the Winchester District. It reviews approaches used for measuring carbon emissions at district level, which calculate emissions relating to electricity consumed locally using the average carbon intensity of the UK Grid as a whole. In particular, it should be noted that local renewable energy generation does not result in any form of ‘carbon credit’ that can be offset against the carbon emissions relating to local electricity consumption. It also notes that, as set out in other STAP reports, emissions for the Winchester District have been steadily declining, but only because the Grid as a whole has been decarbonising, and not because of any measures taken locally. It notes that local commercial scale projects whose generation is exported to the Grid will generate only a very small reduction in local carbon emissions (due to any impact they have on the carbon intensity of the UK as a whole), while the reduction from auto-generation projects (where electricity generated is used on-site and therefore reduces electricity consumed from the Grid) will depend on the current UK Grid carbon intensity, and will therefore fall over time as the UK continues to decarbonise. It concludes that local renewables therefore unfortunately have only a limited impact on the carbon footprint for the District. The key recommendations are that WCC and HCC should set targets for local renewables and monitor progress against them, and that local action plans and reporting should make it clear that the emission reductions from local commercial scale renewables mainly arise at national level, and are the local contribution towards the national effort; they are not a reduction in the carbon footprint of the Winchester District itself.