The recent protests by Youth Strike 4 Climate, in Winchester and elsewhere, by Extinction Rebellion in London, and Greta Thunberg’s recent speech to MPs and the media have all raised the profile of the need for urgent action on climate change.
But in the understandable resulting euphoria it is important to recall what climate scientists are actually saying. We have been told by the media that if we don’t act now to reduce climate change the world as we know it will come to an end. This blog is intended to show that we definitely do have to act now but the deadline of 12 years is simply a gross oversimplification of what climate scientists are telling us.
Here are some examples of what we’ve been told:
The Guardian, 8 October 2018, headline “We have 12 years to limit climate change catastrophe, warns UN”.
The BBC, 14 March 2019 headline “Scientists say we have 12 years to stop the planet warming above 1.5C.”
The Extinction Rebellion website states “Extinction Rebellion is a movement made up of people from all walks of life. It started in response to the IPCC report that we only have 12 years to stop catastrophic climate change …..”.
Predicting the future
One of the trickiest concepts is around the changes to the ‘Earth System’. We need to start with the realisation that it is mostly a lumbering beast that reacts gradually, on human time-scales, to changes that are imposed on it. It also contains a lot of random variations such as are caused by the weather which varies from day to day far more than the climate varies in a more systematic fashion say over a few years.
The Earth system, although it contains some major components such as the atmosphere, the oceans and the land surface with its ice sheets, mountains, deserts and plains, also includes plants and animals that change with the seasons. So you can imagine how hard it is for climate scientists, even with the biggest and fastest computers, to come up with models that can accurately predict the future. But there’s no other way that this can be done! Therefore we have to understand this is why, when scientists make climate predictions, they do so as best they can by stating the uncertainty or probability of a particular future event like the average global surface temperature reaching 1.5°C warming above pre-industrial times.
What the scientists say (IPCC 1.5°C Report, October 2019)
If you’ve read so far, you’re in a position to begin to take on board the actual results of the report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) published in October 2018. This report was requested by the United Nations specifically to look into the impacts of global warming of 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels.
Today the Earth has already warmed by around 1°C and we see the devastation that is causing in many parts of the world whether by wildfires, heatwaves, droughts, floods or storms. In addition sea level is inexorably rising and threatening some coastal cities. Another 0.5°C of warming will decimate coral reefs and include more extreme weather events, coastal flooding, melting of Arctic ice and mountain glaciers, and damage to biodiversity hotspots.
One of the first things the report says is “Global warming is likely to reach 1.5°C between 2030 and 2052 if it continues to increase at the current rate”. Thus we see that 2030 is the earliest the world can reach 1.5°C so that claims that we have only 12 years are a very one-sided interpretation of this statement. Of course there is the proviso that emissions continue at their present rate but likely changes either way will only change that date by months rather than by years.
The report then goes on to summarise the results of computer modelling of the rest of the century assuming different scenarios. It says that for those models where the global temperature does not exceed or only slightly exceeds 1.5°C warming the global emissions of carbon dioxide, the most important greenhouse gas, have to decline by about 45% from 2010 levels by 2030 and then reach net zero emissions by about 2050 (half the models indicate somewhere between 2045 and 2055). This is a very different situation from encountering ‘catastrophic climate change’ in 2030.
Is there an emergency?
Yes. It is very clear from the science that we have to act now and the use of words like emergency, crisis and very urgent are entirely appropriate. Consider how the world and our lives will have to change if our emissions in 2030 need to be around half of what they were in 2010. We are less likely to be flying off on long-haul trips to take holidays abroad, consuming relatively large quantities of natural gas to heat our poorly insulated or draughty homes, or driving around in oversized and heavy cars with huge manufacturing carbon footprints.
However taking personal actions will not be enough. A lot more can be, and has to be, done now by national governments, through relevant and effective legislation and by large corporations. If we start today a lot can be achieved over time. Delay is not an option because not taking action now will only lead to more difficult and disagreeable changes later.
Your first action could be to sign up to receive WinACC’s regular free electronic newsletters at www.winacc.org.uk. This will help you to keep abreast of relevant local events and to get further involved in WinACC’s activities if you wish.
[My gnawing concerns on this topic were propelled into action by reading a blog by Myles Allen, a lead author of the IPCC Report, on the same issue. This can be found at The Conversation, 18 April 2019; https://theconversation.com/uk/environment]
Prof. Bob Whitmarsh 24/4/19