Winchester Green Fair – ask us a question

At the WinACC stall on 20 September we solicited questions from visitors and WinACC members.  

If there are themes, my impression is that people are concerned about plastic and feel a lack of agency to address their concerns. 

The feeling was that even when green measures such as food waste collection are adopted by local or national government they seem to be run by faceless corporations without any local opportunities for engagement. 

Responsibility for carbon emissions is another theme. 

We have tried to supply some tentative answers/comments/reflections below. 

Question: When are things really going to change? 

In spite of the various initiatives such as COP meetings, annual greenhouse gas emissions continue to increase, temperatures continue to rise, and many countries and political parties are either doing nothing or actively obstructing steps to mitigate climate change. 

On the plus side 

  • the majority of people in the UK accept that climate change is real and favour taking action when familiar with the facts. 
  • Green technologies such as solar and wind have proved more successful than anticipated and often make economic as well as environmental sense.  

Read more: 

New public polling: Behind the noise on net zero 

Why did renewables become so cheap so fast? 

Question: Why is the carbon footprint of an avocado lower than that of local cheese? 

Because cheese is a dairy product its carbon footprint includes the emissions associated with cattle rearing. Although the carbon footprint of milk is quite a bit less than meat, producing 1 kg of cheese typically uses around 10 kg of milk so cheese often has a higher carbon footprint than pork for example. 

In contrast avocados grow on trees requiring a lot fewer resources and creating far less carbon emissions than dairy products. Avocados production does consume a relatively large amount of water although this is generally considered to be far lower than for dairy and meat products. 

Unlike some fresh vegetables avocados are usually transported by sea, not air freighted.  

Read more: 

Are avocados worse for the environment than meat? 

CO2 of everything 

Energy balance and greenhouse gas emissions in organic and conventional avocado orchards in Mexico 

The Truth about Cheese 

Question: Why should I do anything when China …? 

The suggestion is often that China’s greenhouse gas emissions dwarf the UK’s so reducing the UK’s emissions will have little effect on global warming. 

This is a familiar argument in many contexts when individuals are confronted with problems that require collective action. The UK carbon emissions attributable to each individual are about the same in China when emissions imported and exported through trade are considered. The UK also has significant potential for further generation of renewable energy so it seems reasonable that the UK should take their share of emissions reduction. 

Read more: 

How do CO2 emissions compare when we adjust for trade? 

Greenhouse gas emissions and trade, UK: 2024 

Questions: Talk to me about hard plastic recycling and why it doesn’t happen. Why can’t I recycle plastic? 

There are essentially two common types of plastic – thermoplastic and thermoset. Thermosets make up about 12% of plastic production. Thermoplastics are generally pliable (e.g. milk bottles) and relatively frequently recycled while thermosets are rigid/hard (e.g. printed circuit boards, wind turbine blades). 

Generally, thermosets are harder to recycle both because they are hard to break down and because they often incorporate other materials such as carbon fibre. 

Research into recycling thermosets seems to be focussed mainly on making the formulations more recyclable. 

Plastics are prominent pollutants both in terms of pollution including microplastics and the emissions they entail. Creation and disposal of plastics contribute around 3% of global emissions (although sometimes this can be less than the alternatives). Reduction and recycling are therefore significant in mitigating the pollution and climate change. 

Locally work is under way to upgrade the local materials recycling facility (MRF) by 2028 although it’s not clear this will include handling of thermosets. 

Read more: 

Plastic recycling: A panacea or environmental pollution problem 

How rigid plastic is recycled 

Recycling of Thermoset Materials and Thermoset-Based Composites: Challenge and Opportunity 

PCB recycling 

UK Government 

How much of global greenhouse gas emissions come from plastics? 

Green light to boosting recycling rates in Hampshire 

The Rubbish Book A Complete Guide to Recycling By James Piper  

Question: Why are we, the individuals, being made to feel responsible when it’s actually big corporations? 

The suggestion is that the majority of greenhouse emissions come from the activity of corporations either from their decision to mine fossil fuels, while ignoring or opposing alternatives, which are then burnt, or from their use of energy producing things we use. Consumers and citizens have often had little input to these decisions. 

Actually, it’s the responsibility of big corporations AND individuals both through consumer choice (think emission from long-haul flying and making/driving SUVs) and by exercising their democratic rights. 

While consumers arguably can choose what they consume or use, often they have had little say in decisions that affect greenhouse gas emissions. Also, government action is often required to enable consumers to reduce their emissions – for example by supporting public transport or enabling choices about energy supply. 

Read more: 

Who’s Really Responsible for Climate Change? 

Only 57 Producers are Responsible for 80% of all Fossil Fuel and Cement CO2 Emissions since 2016 

Question: Why is composting at home worse for the environment than the new food waste recycling system being delivered by WCC? 

Winchester City Council recognises that some people compost food waste and encourage people to continue doing that. 

If food waste ends up in landfill it can release methane – a powerful greenhouse gas. The anaerobic digestion (AD) process used by the council’s contractors to process food waste also releases methane, but this is captured in the sealed processing unit and can be used commercially as fuel. Furthermore, AD decomposes more waste and more types of waste than regular composting with the residual waste as a useful by-product. 

Read more: 

Household recycling in England 

Food waste FAQs 

Food waste recycling collections 

Why should I recycle my food waste 

What if I already compost my food waste? 

Questions: Do supermarkets HAVE to use so much plastic wrapping? Why aren’t retailers made to dispose of packaging that they sell goods to us in? 

Obviously, the answer is ‘no’. From a personal perspective surely we could start with eliminating half-full packages, packets of packets of crisps etc. Greenpeace suggests a major area for reduction is with fresh fruit and vegetables, and this option does seem to be available at our local Sainsburys to those that want it – with self-checkouts increasingly simplified for this. Our local Sainsburys store can accept some returned plastic packaging for recycling but this doesn’t seem to be widely used. 

Plastic packaging (and plastic in general) has turned into a large and growing many-dimensional issue. As the extent of microplastic pollution has become apparent some are revisiting the pros and cons of paper vs plastic packaging. 

Read more: 

15 ways to reduce your plastic waste 

Greenpeace How supermarkets can cut plastic packaging in half by 2025 

Designing out plastic pollution with the circular economy 

EU Regulation Limits PFAS in Food Packaging, Bans Single-Use Plastic Packaging for Produce 

Plastic vs Paper Packaging: The Pros and Cons 

Sainsbury’s Recycling Centre Locations and What They Accept 

Questions: Don’t we need more oil?  Why do we oppose UK oil fields when it means importing oil from others? 

A CabonBrief article discussed this issue. Essentially the main arguments are that: 

  • We have already discovered far more fossil fuels than can be used in the medium term if catastrophic climate change is to be avoided. 
  • Any oil and gas extracted from the North Sea is sold on the open market so would hardly affect UK prices and certainly not lower UK prices compared to other countries. 

Read more: 

Factcheck: Why banning new North Sea oil and gas is not a ‘Just Stop Oil plan’ 

Analysis: Cutting the ‘green crap’ has added £2.5bn to UK energy bills 

Compiled by Robin Speed with input from Phil Gagg, Mike Biden, Brian Shorter, Bob Whitmarsh and Kay Mitchell. 

October 2025 

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: