​​​Fawley Green Hydrogen – subsidising oil refining?​ 

​This article was written by Robin Speed, Chair of the Winchester Action on the Climate Crisis (WinACC) Scientific and Technical Advisory Panel in March 2026, in response to enquiries about the proposed new green hydrogen plant at Fawley in Southampton.​ 

In January Hynamics ran a community event about a proposed ‘Green Hydrogen’ project on the site of the old Fawley Power Station near Southampton. The project is part of HAR2, a UK government plan to increase low carbon hydrogen production capacity. 

Hydrogen will be produced from water by electrolysis using green electricity purchased over the national grid. The government will subsidize the project by guaranteeing the price the hydrogen produced is sold for. 

As previously discussed by WinACC, hydrogen has a place in decarbonisation – for example in the chemical industry as a replacement for fossil-fuel based chemical feedstocks and as a green fuel. However, rather than replacing fossil fuel use, all the hydrogen produced in this project will be used in ExxonMobil’s nearby oil refinery helping to produce petrol, aviation fuel and other crude oil products. 

Although the project will only produce a fraction of the refinery’s hydrogen requirements it will still use around three times the average electricity consumed by the whole of Winchester District when producing hydrogen at full capacity. 

How does this fit with government green energy plans? 

The short answer is that arguably the hydrogen produced by this project will replace hydrogen produced from less green sources – for example grey hydrogen – meaning the oil refinery and therefore the fuel produced by it will have an overall lower carbon footprint. 

The government’s plan is aimed at stimulating low carbon hydrogen production capacity. This is achieved by subsidising the price of the hydrogen produced for each project as set out in the government’s Hydrogen Production Business Model (HPBM). There is no stipulation about how the hydrogen is used, the applicant simply has to show that there is a viable buyer (‘off-take’ party such as the refinery) for the hydrogen at a reasonable price. 

To qualify for the subsidy the hydrogen produced must be ‘low carbon’ as defined by the government’s Low Carbon Hydrogen Standard (LCHS). WinACC has previously discussed some of the concern surrounding this system in the context of ‘blue’ hydrogen produced using Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS). 

The hydrogen will be produced from water using electricity (electrolysis) with the electricity will come from the mains. Because mains electricity is not ‘green’ – coming partly from gas fuelled power stations – the LCHS requires the parties to purchase enough electricity from mains suppliers to bring the emissions from the total project within the standard from renewable sources (delivered to the mains) – plus enough extra to cover transmission and delivery losses along with the normal supply. 

What reaction has there been? 

There has been some comment on this proposal from the Solent Protection Society. ExxonMobil’s previous abandoned application for a blue hydrogen (carbon capture and storage) facility on the same site also provoked serious opposition. 

A planning request for a scoping decision for the environmental impact assessment (EIA) was concluded on 19 December 2025. However, there were no public comments at this planning stage – indicating these projects may be going largely under the radar. Furthermore, none of the consultees, including England and HCC minerals, requested that greenhouse gas emissions from the operations be considered as part of the environmental assessment. These omissions do seem to risk losing focus on emissions in the cracks between local planning and the government subsidy scheme which only covers hydrogen production emissions. 

So, is it a good idea? 

The use of mains electricity rather than using renewables directly to produce hydrogen seems unnecessary. But current electrolysers make more economic sense with a reasonably steady power supply which may not be available at sites of renewable generation. This does mean that transmission losses will be incurred before any hydrogen is generated. Also these projects are large electricity consumers and will compete with other electricity users, increasing the overall load on the grid. 

It is hard to understand why this is a sensible use of taxpayer money. Clearly the hydrogen used for oil refining will not contribute to long-term decarbonisation. Furthermore the subsidies paid for by the taxpayer will continue for 15 years. 

There is a lot of hype behind hydrogen, much of it coming from fossil fuel companies. Yet industry is not prepared to invest in this area, instead expecting to be subsidised for every small step however perverse the direction is. 

In conclusion, WinACC remains perplexed by the government’s hydrogen strategy and choice of partners when there appear to be far more worthwhile investments in other (non-hydrogen) areas which don’t consume large amounts of renewable energy and subsidies for apparent greenwashing of petrol and diesel. 

Robin Speed March 2026. 


Numbers

Hydrogen production rate

HAR2 projects are quantified by how much hydrogen will be produced per second when running at maximum capacity. This is specified rather confusingly in megawatts (MW): 120 MW for the Fawley project.

The 120 MW value can be converted to kilogrammes (kg) of hydrogen by dividing by 141.8 giving 0.85 kg per second, or about 3 tonnes of hydrogen per hour.

Electricity consumption

The value of 120 MW is the ‘energy content’ of the hydrogen produced (although only between 50%-60% would be recovered when the hydrogen is used to produce electricity for example). To produce this amount of hydrogen using electrolysis is typically only around 60% efficient so about 200 MW of mains electricity would be needed.

In 2023 Winchester District consumed 556 Gigawatt hours of electricity which is on average 63.5 MW or about a third of the 200 MW the electrolysis plant would consume when running at maximum capacity.

Subsidy

The subsidy for HAR2 hasn’t been set yet, but for the previous HAR1 set of projects the strike price (government guaranteed price) was £241 per megawatt hour (MWh) of hydrogen, or 24.1p per kilowatt hour (kWh). The two major costs are the capital cost of the electrolyser equipment and the mains electricity. This price can be put into some context by observing that the current government price cap for domestic customers is around 26p per kWh. So people won’t be doing this at home any time soon.

Low carbon hydrogen

As noted above the government has a standard for low carbon hydrogen (LCHS) in a nutshell this limits the carbon emissions for each unit of hydrogen product to 20g CO2e/MJLHV (or 2.4 kg CO2e / kg H2). The standard then prescribes how the emissions should be calculated for a range of permitted scenarios including the scenario here where mains electricity, some of which is from renewables providers, is used in to split water info hydrogen and oxygen.

One drawback of this standard is that there is no incentive for a project to reduce emissions below this threshold which arguably is too high and often does not account for all potential emissions. It should be noted that the EU and USA (at time of writing) have similar low carbon hydrogen standards.

Water

It is interesting to know how much water will be consumed each second. This is approximately the amount of water that contains 0.85 kg of hydrogen or 7.6 kg per second. 1 kg of water is 1 litre of water. This comes to about 27420 litres per hour. Since homes in the UK consume on average 136.5 litres of water per person per day, this the equivalent to the water consumption of around 4800 people.

Claimed carbon savings

The proposal claims that 100,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide  (CO2) emissions per year will be saved. This is presumably the emissions which would have been created by alternative hydrogen production. One common method used is to burn natural gas in the presence of stream (steam methane reforming). Using a figure of 11 kg of CO2 emitted per kg of hydrogen this works out at around 300,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide per year if the plant runs at maximum capacity all year. Even hydrogen produced to the low carbon standard (LCHS) would still produce 2.4 kg of CO2 for each kg of hydrogen produced so by no means all emissions will be avoided.


Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: