Pensions, investments and climate change

I used to read about “divestment” campaigns, which campaign against investments in oil and fossil fuel companies and wonder what it had to do with me.

It was a long time before I realised that I too had savings invested in fossil fuel. The penny dropped when I went to a WinACC meeting on “Saving for Good”.

I’m hoping this blog will explain what I learnt, and what I decided to do. Although I first wrote it in 2020, I checked it in April 2026 and it’s still true and relevant.

But first, a warning – I’m obviously not a financial adviser, and I’m not allowed to give you advice on your investments or pension savings. I’m just describing my own experience.

What I used to think

I’d sign petitions asking banks, universities, the Church of England and similar large institutions to take their money out of oil companies like BP and Shell. But that was it, right? Advice about taking your money out – ending investment, or in other words, divesting – was for rich people, who make investments and track the profits from their stocks and shares.

I can’t take my money out when I haven’t put money in, can I?

So what did I learn?

I’d never taken much interest in pensions. And I’d certainly not really thought about where the money that would be paying me a pension when I retired was being saved up. I suppose I vaguely thought that it sat in a bank, kept safe by administrators – rather like keeping it under the bed or in a pot buried in the back garden.

In reality, the pension companies invest it.

The people responsible for any UK pension fund have a responsibility to the people who get, or will get, a pension, using the ‘care, skill and diligence’ a prudent person would exercise when investing for someone for whom they feel ‘morally bound to provide’.

So they used to argue that they couldn’t take ethics into account in making decisions about where to invest. But more and more financial experts have been pointing out that climate change will affect investments.

In particular, money invested in fossil fuels like oil and gas is unlikely to be safe in the long term. If the Government is serious about reaching net zero carbon by 2050, shares in BP, Shell and similar companies could drop very dramatically because we will no longer want their fossil fuels. The Minister for Pensions and Financial Inclusion made this clear on 1 July 2019 in a speech about the role of pension funds in tackling climate change: “… in a scenario of a 2-degree increase in global temperatures, a modest estimate suggests that oil and gas will have lost 94% of its value by 2050.” I updated this at Easter 2026, when the prices of fossil fuels were going up, down and up again, but that  doesn’t change my understanding of the long term.

State pension

The first step was easy. I’d be getting a state pension, but I learnt that this didn’t mean that the Government had been saving up money for me. So I didn’t have to worry about where they might have been keeping “my” savings – there weren’t any.

My private pension

As well as a state pension and a local government pension, I’d paid regular monthly amounts into a private pension when I’d been in a job that didn’t have a pension.

I was pretty confident that I’d chosen on option called something like “Ethical Investment” so I wasn’t worried.

However, when I checked, I discovered that I put my money in so long ago that “ethical” had meant no investments in alcohol, cigarettes or weapons. “Ethics” then had nothing to do with coal, oil or gas. So my first thought was to take the lot out, and buy shares in a windfarm.

But first, I got free advice about how pensions work from Pension Wise, a Government scheme for people over 50. I went to an appointment with a pension specialist based at Eastleigh Citizens Advice. They explained the options for taking my pension money –  pension options, how each option is taxed, and next steps. I’d recommend anyone to take advantage of this free service.

They said it wasn’t wise to take all my money out of my private pension at once because of the tax implications. So after some hunting on the pension firm’s website and a phone call, I found a list of all their different funds, and what type of investments each made. One of them had a much lower percentage of investment in fossil fuel, so I asked them to swap me to that fund. This was easy, and cost me nothing. Not perfect, but much better than nothing.

Good with Money keeps an updated list of the top ethical pensions. NB Good for Money says “This site is a journalistic website and its contents should be viewed as information and ideas and not financial advice.”

Local Government pension

Because I’d worked for local government, I knew I’d get a pension linked to my salary. It didn’t occur to me to wonder where that money was being kept. I certainly didn’t register that the Hampshire Pension Fund, which looks after my pension money was investing “my” money, the money that would pay for my future pension, in company shares.

When I did, I got together with other people to ask the Hampshire Pension Fund Board about their investment policies. Did they put our money into fossil fuel companies? Find out more about our campaign Hampshire Pension Fund Divest.

My own savings

I appreciate that many people reading this won’t have any savings, so please skip this section if it isn’t relevant to you.

I’d never had any significant savings of my own. Certainly not enough to think about investing it to make money. I mostly just left it in the bank and didn’t reflect that the bank would be investing it. I did put a bit into Shared Interest who had impressed me. They lend your money to Fair Trade people around the globe, and you can choose to take no interest if you want – see this short film about them.

Then after my parents died, for the first time in my life I had some savings for a rainy day. So what should I do with it?

I thought I should put some into community energy schemes, helping pay for solar panels on school roofs or wind turbines. I could see interesting and worthwhile projects, for example on Ethex. But that turned out to be complicated. There was a risk that such a scheme might fail and I’d lose my money, so I needed to spread it out across different schemes. That seemed fair enough, even if it would be a hassle. Worse, all the schemes I could find included a warning that I might not be able to get my money back the moment I needed it. This seemed alarming – if a rainy day came, I’d need my cash promptly.

I decided that I should find an investment manager (a firm rather than one person) that would invest my savings for me rather than trying to do it myself, which would invest it only in ethical projects. Having heard and been impressed by a speaker from WHEB , I chose them. They describe themselves as “a positive impact investor focused on the opportunities created by the transition to a low carbon and sustainable global economy.”  They spread my money across lots of companies, and I could get it out at once when I needed to. So far, five years later, I’ve had no problems.

There are of course other investment managers offering similar services.

What can you do?

Think about where your pension money might be invested.

If you are in a private pension scheme, ask them if they have a fund that doesn’t invest in fossil fuel. If so, ask if you can switch to it. If not, why not?

If your money is in a scheme chosen by your employers, ask where it is invested. If you don’t like the answer, ask to see their policy on climate risks. With luck, you’ll be able to find colleagues to join you in this. The Trade Union will almost certainly help.

If you work in or get a pension from the local government pension scheme – which also covers some people in the Fire and Rescue Service, and universities – join our group and help exert pressure on the Hampshire Pension Fund to divest. Contact HPF.Divest@gmail.com

If you are lucky enough to have any savings, review where you keep them, and whether you could invest them in a more ethical way. Comparethemarket.com has a section on ethical banking, even for current accounts, which might be of interest.

And finally – join divestment campaigns.

Fossil Free is an international divestment movement calling for organisations, institutions and individuals to end their financial support for the fossil fuel industry. They say that a growing number of universities, cities, religious institutions and organisations around the world are committing to divest.

Keep it in the Ground  represents over 400 civil society organizations from more than 60 countries, tens of millions of people around the world, calling on world leaders to put an immediate halt to new fossil fuel development and pursue a just transition to renewable energy with a managed decline of the fossil fuel industry.

ShareAction helped us tackle Hampshire Pension Fund.

Chris Holloway

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: