This is a question that has been widely discussed in recent weeks (March-April 2026) frequently accompanied by misinformation. This blog attempts to present the arguments for and against more drilling based on usually reliable sources.

Let’s start with some basic definitions.
- ‘North Sea’ is usually shorthand, as used here, for the UK Continental Shelf, including that part of the North Sea in the UK’s Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) as well as similar areas west of Shetland, in which oil and gas have already been extracted.
- It is important to distinguish between the terms ‘reserves’ and ‘resources’. Reserves refers to oil or gas that is already discovered and recoverable and the extraction of which is commercially viable. Resources means the amount of oil or gas that might exist underground under favourable assumptions.
North Sea output has been declining
Oil and gas fields, particularly ones like the ‘mature’ North Sea, are dynamic in the sense that to continuously exploit them new activity is needed to maintain production just to replace reserves that are being extracted. However, all fields contain finite amounts of oil or gas and it can become harder with time to preserve the rate of production after the easier-to-reach reserves have been used up. For example, over the 5-year period 2019-2024, the UK replaced only 14% of the reserves that were extracted. The North Sea has been in long-term decline with production down by over a quarter since 1983. The reasons are partly the result of government policy but also the recognition that today returns on investment are better elsewhere. By the end of 2024 UK reserves of oil and gas at the then current rate of production were set to last for only another seven years. It is estimated that the North Sea is now effectively 90% ‘drained dry’.
Will extracting more North Sea oil or gas decrease household energy bills?
No. One reason is that the prices of oil and gas are set on international markets and the UK simply does not have sufficient influence on markets or the ability to extract, refine and use oil (gas generally needs less processing) all by itself, even if it wanted to, so we end up paying as much for wholesale energy as anyone else. Another reason that our electricity bills are higher than elsewhere in Europe is the way that electricity prices are tied to the wholesale price of gas instead of reflecting the fact that a lot of electricity comes from cheaper renewables. A third reason is that our government takes taxes and levies paid by oil and gas companies for itself; however it has been estimated that even if these were distributed to consumers their bills would fall by less than 5%.
Does North Sea gas have a lower carbon footprint than imported fuels?
Yes, this is true but only just. Because of the energy required to liquify natural gas (LNG) and import it by sea on average LNG has a carbon footprint which is 2.7 times more carbon emissions intensive than North Sea gas production. However, when the gas is eventually burnt, wherever it comes from, it produces much more carbon dioxide. The totals of production and combustion are 351 kg CO2 for North Sea gas and 388 kg CO2 for LNG for a single barrel of oil equivalent.
Would more drilling in the North Sea contribute to greater security?
No. It is a fact that as North Sea output has declined the UK has become increasingly reliant on imported energy. Although we were a net energy exporter in 2000 by 2010 the UK was dependent on imports for 30% of its energy supplies and this had increased to 44% by 2024. Even with further drilling, the government’s North Sea Transition Authority expects the UK’s gas output to have fallen steadily, relative to 2000, by 97% and oil by 91% by 2050 so obviously this will not fill the gap. Clearly more North Sea drilling cannot add significantly to energy security.
Would more drilling in the North Sea make the UK more resilient to global energy shocks?
Unlikely. Resilience will depend more on increasing stocks of oil and gas extracted from the North Sea, and elsewhere, and the duration of any actual ‘energy shock’. The UK currently holds more than 90-days worth of oil stocks but gas storage is enough for at most 12 days of average winter consumption. In an emergency the production rate from the North Sea would be so low that by itself it could never meet the UK’s day-to-day demands for energy.
What is the future of the North Sea?
Production from the North Sea oil and gas fields is in severe decline. No doubt production will usefully continue until it is no longer economic but the fields as a whole are ‘drained dry’.
Global heating: the ‘elephant in the room’.
What is usually missing from discussions of more drilling for hydrocarbons (oil and gas) in the North Sea, or anywhere else for that matter, is the impact on global heating of not only the extraction of oil and gas but, more importantly, its downstream combustion. Since the 19th century mankind, led by the Industrial Revolution in the UK, has been extracting and burning more fossil fuel hydrocarbons year on year. It began with coal and moved on to the oil and gas on which we largely depend today. it is almost unavoidable that burning fossil fuels emits greenhouse gases and especially carbon dioxide. Globally carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has increased by over 40% in the last hundred years and by 32% since 1970. This has driven, and is driving, global temperatures to as high as 1.5°C above pre-industrial values. And we frequently see the consequences of global heating today as deadly heatwaves, storms, droughts, floods and rising sea-levels happen almost everywhere. It is abundantly clear that any future exploitation of oil and gas, and especially the issue of new exploration licences, must be avoided wherever possible even if this means leaving reserves in the ground as stranded assets.
What role can renewable energy play?

A crucial part of the solution to reduce and eventually stop global heating is to rely more and more on renewable energy while phasing out (transitioning away from) fossil fuels. Although renewable energy can be expensive to install it provides access to infinite sources of free energy in the forms of solar, wind, geothermal, tides and running water. Energy storage and electricity grid updates are also part of the solution. However, it is less obvious that this also has to be done urgently, meaning as fast as possible, because, in spite of the world’s efforts so far, global greenhouse emissions continue to increase, albeit at a slower rate, and have yet to show a steady decline.
A more detailed discussion can be found at https://www.carbonbrief.org/factcheck-nine-false-or-misleading-myths-about-north-sea-oil-and-gas/
Bob Whitmarsh
April 2026