Hydrogen, our latest report

In 2020 there were a lot of press reports on the rise of hydrogen as a green fuel for combatting climate change, many reporting strong backing from fossil fuel companies. Several hydrogen projects are being sponsored by the UK government. This is a controversial development because hydrogen is mainly produced today from natural gas,  although it can also be produced from water using electricity by electrolysis. At a meeting of WinACC’s Science and Technology Advisory Panel (STAP) we were unsure of the merits of adopting hydrogen – knowing some of its limitations but being aware of the relatively small proportion of total energy use currently provided by green electricity. Thus, in December 2020, STAP decided to review this area, with input from the WinACC Transport Group who had also been following the hydrogen debate.

Writing about hydrogen’s potential role is a challenge because it is a complex technical area involving chemistry, thermodynamics, engineering, economics and even geology. STAP members have a variety of interests which helped us to create a list of references and sources. Some of us also had a friend or family member already involved in or interested in hydrogen. CarbonBrief wrote a report on hydrogen in November 2020 which helped us to get started. We did not want to simply duplicate CarbonBrief’s work but felt we should present some facts and figures and the main arguments for and against hydrogen in key hydrogen application areas – energy storage, transport, and heating. We decided not to look at industrial applications although those are important.

As we started in earnest it became clear there was a huge amount of material we could look at, including the large number and variety of projects worldwide and the rapidly evolving technology. In the near to medium term, as renewable electricity remains limited in supply, most hydrogen will have to be produced from natural gas. This requires the use of carbon capture and storage (CCS) – a controversial process – for it to be a low carbon energy source. Hydrogen is not burnt in hydrogen vehicles, the energy is released as electricity in a fuel cell that operates at normal ambient temperature. Not all of us knew that fuels such as ammonia can also be used in fuel cells, which may be useful in future. Substantial amounts of hydrogen are used industrially today – for example in ammonia production (e.g. for fertilizer), oil refining and margarine production.

We hope that our report gives some insight into on the production and possible uses of hydrogen as a carbon-free fuel and helps to explain the potential issues. Many of these stem from energy losses that occur when producing, storing, or using hydrogen. For instance, if electricity is used to produce hydrogen for a fuel cell, the cell will only produce some 30% of the original electrical energy.

What can individuals do? Whatever the outcome of technology decisions, innovations etc the debate is essentially driven by the energy shortfalls anticipated as fossil fuel reliance is reduced, so steps to reduce energy consumption and waste will always help. At the same time we can inform ourselves, listen to others, make up our own minds and contribute to the debate.

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: