Land suitable for solar farms is scarce

One medium-sized solar farm in each of Winchester’s  eligible parishes would provide Winchester District’s fair share of the renewable electricity that’s needed to replace the energy from burning fossil fuels in the national electricity grid. More about this in our blog ‘Every parish can learn to love solar farms.’

This is easier said than done. Where do we find the 2,500 acres of suitable land referred to? 

First of all, there’s the question of whether the land is suitable. 

  • It is better to build a solar farm on land that isn’t high quality for growing crops. The quality of farmland in Winchester District is not the highest quality Grade 1 or 2 and most is classified Grade 3 which means there are limitations that affect the agricultural use including the choice of crops to be grown.
  • The land must be flat, or nearly so. 
  • To be financially viable, a solar farm needs a site of at least 50 acres, close to an electricity substation and its distribution lines. 

Then there’s the question of permission. 

As we’ve previously discussed, parishes in the South Downs National Park Authority aren’t likely to get permission for a solar farm. Then there are over 100 Scheduled Monuments in our District, and Sites of Special Scientific Interest which will be protected from development. There are also no brownfield opportunities for solar farms in Winchester District. The City Council’s Brownfield Register 2020 contains 18 addresses, all of which are holding out for residential development and none of which is large enough for a financially viable solar farm.

WinACC has been informed that farmers who own suitable land (which may obtain planning consent for a solar farm) apparently do not respond as positively as might be expected to offers by energy companies of a long term inflation-linked income. Given the market volatility that plagues farm revenues, this is surprising and WinACC is keen to understand the basis of any reticence and whether any helpful information or support might be provided.

These issues whittle down the number of prospective sites to a relatively small number in relation to the land area available in the District.

All the more important that these scarce sites do get planning permission to generate renewable energy. And the declaration of a climate emergency underlines the need for action.

Is this happening?

Six solar farm applications have been submitted since the climate emergency was declared by Winchester City Council. One has been approved and one withdrawn. Four are still being considered. 

It is disappointing that some of the formal consultees, such as the South Downs National Park Authority, Historic England and the City Council’s Archaeology team, don’t seem to consider the public benefit represented by renewable energy when they express their views. 

It is also disappointing that so many residents object, recycling poorly informed criticisms of solar farms. Around half of these objections can be summarised in the single phrase: “We support renewable energy, but not here.” 

The local community is key to the success or failure of applications to build a solar farm.

With 2021’s extreme weather and the UN declaration of Code Red for Humanity, people are worried. That disquiet needs to be channelled into local support for a solar farm. Then councillors are much more likely to approve the planning application. 

Local support needs more than a letter-writing campaign. 

It means developing a constructive relationship with the developer of the solar project. Developers welcome local leadership, for example from the Parish Council. Local people prefer to discuss new ideas with each other and with local organisations, not with big business outsiders. The developer may not have the right people in the area to lead the case for support. 

The developer can also help the community. A large renewable energy business can help deliver a parish climate action plan. Even more if it includes a community energy project, where their expertise and equipment could make a big difference. 

A solar farm contributing to national grid decarbonisation and a community energy project delivering local security of supply and price – that’s a formidable model, delivering multiple public benefits, and realising the potential of a scarce land resource. 

Keep watching our solar farm campaigns page to hear about local solar farms that need your support, or sign up to receive WinACC News where we’ll let you know about them too.

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: