The following blog post was written by Robin Speed, one of our volunteers. Robin currently chairs our Scientific and Technical Advisory Panel (STAP).
Net Zero, Tony Blair, Spanish Power Failure and Electricity Prices
Net Zero has been much in the news recently with former Prime Minister Tony Blair saying the UK must change direction, two of the main parties saying the public are fed up of paying for Net Zero policies which should be abandoned, and claims that a power outage in Spain was caused by too much renewable energy generation.
But to me these confirm that in the UK many of our Net Zero policies are not only the most effective for reducing emissions in the long term but are also saving money in the short term. In contrast the main alternatives proposed by critics are carbon capture and storage and a rapid expansion of nuclear power
The report from the Tony Blair Institute (TBI) says that, since fossil fuel use is still rising and will continue to rise, current policies relying mainly on renewable energy with targets set by international COP meetings will fail. Instead, it recommends additional interventions (referred to as ‘disruptions’). These include measures to capture carbon dioxide from fossil fuel burning: carbon capture and storage (CSS) where carbon dioxide is retrieved when fossil fuels are burnt, and ‘direct air capture’ (DAC) when carbon dioxide is captured from atmosphere.
A rapid expansion of nuclear power is called for and different forms of finance such as philanthropic sources are suggested. Some of the proposals such as tree planting, use of technology to improve energy efficiency are already mainstream. The report does mention briefly the contribution of fossil-fuel company lobbying and disinformation to the lack of progress but does not suggest taxing them or their products to fund the proposed interventions.
Political pressure to abandon Net Zero focusses mainly on the cost, with the suggestion that people would be, or think they would be, better off without Net Zero policies, also highlighted by the TBI.
The recent widespread power failure in Spain has been blamed on over-reliance on renewable energy. While different theories as to the exact cause are still circulating this certainly highlights the technical challenges of maintaining a power grid supplied from a wide number and variety of generation sources.
So should we continue with the current policies in the face of these developments? There is no question that fossil fuel and atmospheric carbon dioxide (and methane) levels are increasing at disappointing rates. Renewable energy sources (including controversial biomass) satisfied just 15.5 percent of total UK energy demand in 2024. Tony Blair’s intervention was seen as particularly significant because his government drove green energy adoption in the early 2000s, although his report does not call for Net Zero to be abandoned.
However, wind and solar are a significant success as evidenced by Spain’s example These technologies have exceeded technological predictions so it seems wrong for the TBI to blame lack of progress on prioritizing them. Indeed, progress would have been greater (and UK electricity prices lower) if the cheapest form of renewable energy – onshore wind – had not been effectively blocked in 2015 by the previous UK government and action by local groups.
Other technologies suggested by the TBI and other net zero critics may have potential and are not being blocked by policy makers, although WinACC’s view is that the main proposals – CCS and nuclear – seem unlikely to deliver significant emissions savings in the medium term and come with significantly higher costs and drawbacks compared with wind and solar.
Many critics in the UK claim net zero policies are increasing energy bills. But arguably pursuing renewables has reduced UK energy bills and could have done so more if these policies had not been curtailed. Furthermore, pricing of electricity is unnecessarily favouring gas due to the way electricity is priced with renewable electricity often priced at gas-fuelled electricity prices and environmental and social tariffs loaded disproportionately onto electricity rather than shared with gas and oil.
Many argue that much political and press commentary misrepresents public opinion which is broadly supportive of net zero. A recent edition of the BBC’s Rare Earth advocated giving greater prominence to local efforts which are effective and increase awareness of ordinary people’s support.
Robin Speed
June 2025