Responding to the draft local plan consultation December 2022

You may find it more useful to go to the page about the 2024 Local Plan consultation.

Use your voice

As discussed on our page talking about the draft Winchester District Local Plan consultation, this is your opportunity to help shape how our District looks for the next few decades. Time is running out to get to net zero carbon emissions (those harmful greenhouse gases that cause climate change).

You need to respond to Winchester City Council via their consultation website.

These are the representations (feedback) that WinACC will be making. We’ve set them out in plan order. They are referenced to paragraph numbers (para) or policy numbers.

Paragraph or policy number

WinACC representation

Local plan introduction

Para 2.11

Providing a list of the evidence base documents is helpful, but looking at the Council’s website not all the documents are listed here.  For clarity please provide a complete list with web links if possible.

Objectives of the local plan

Para 3.7

This paragraph lists the Plan’s objectives for tackling the climate emergency and creating a greener district.  Objective viii refers to maximising the use of low carbon infrastructure and construction etc.  This should be clarified to ensure that it includes renewable energy generation.

Para 3.7

also lists the “vibrant local economy” objectives.  Objective viii should be clarified to ensure that it includes renewable energy generation.

Strategic Policy

Policy SP2

Point vi of the strategy should require non car travel to be prioritised.

Policy SP3

Add, as point vi, development for renewable energy generation as a type of development that will be permitted in the countryside

The role of the Local Plan

Para 4.8

We strongly support this statement.

Carbon neutrality and climate change key issues ( following para 4.11)

Key issue xi

This should be clearer and state that the Council WILL support proposals for low carbon energy infrastructure.

Mitigating and adapting to climate change

Policy CN1

The requirement for an Energy and Carbon Statement should be listed as requirement x.

Energy hierarchy

Policy CN2

The way in which the energy hierarchy has informed and developed the design should be set out in the Energy and Carbon Statement ( in Policy CN1).

Para 4.20

Should clarify which version of the Building Regulations is current.  We assume 2022?

Energy efficiency standards to reduce carbon emissions

Policy CN3

To make this policy clear and robust, explanatory paragraph 2, lines 2/3 should be amended to read “ all new developments SHOULD ( omit “ seek to”)  DEMONSTRATE the lowest level……etc

Policy CN3 i-iv

We strongly endorse points i to iv which set challenging requirements for all new (residential) dwellings. ( NB all dwellings are residential) 

Policy CN3 v

Non – residential development. Point v is inadequate because BREEAM is not a tool for driving zero carbon development.  The following should therefore be added to Point v “ Demand for space heating should be met by renewables”.

Policy CN3

Measurement and verification. 

Please clarify whether the metering, monitoring and reporting strategy will be assessed when determining whether to grant permission and if so how will this be carried out?

Add a requirement for pre occupation verification.

Water efficiency standards in new developments

CN4

We support the water efficiency standards set out in this policy

Para 4.38

We endorse the Plan’s support for retrofitting existing buildings.  We would like this section to go further and state a preference for sensitive retrofitting above demolition and rebuilding. At the very least we would like to see a reference to future guidance on this topic similar to that produced by the Mayor of London: 

https://www.dezeen.com/2022/04/21/london-plan-guidance-retention-sadiq-khan/

Para 4.39

Please change 17% to 100%. This is the “target potential” identified in the Study. And please delete the two sentences about energy potential in the South Downs National Park. There is no content resembling these sentences in the Study.

Para 4.40

Please add a further bullet point: “It would additionally require the potential for wind energy that exists within the District to be activated, as outlined in the Study.”

Para 4.44

Please delete or move to one of the Residential sections. District Energy Systems are not normally structured as community energy and usually necessitate a non-renewable energy source.

Renewable and low carbon energy schemes

CN5

Whilst this represents a permissive policy, it is less permissive than the corresponding Policy in the existing Local Plan, both in wording and in the expanded list of constraints. We suggest a more positive tone wherever possible.

CN5

(viii) If it is necessary to include a lighting condition, we request that it should be no more restrictive that the policies for equestrian, leisure and rural developments.

CN5

x) we request that this condition be omitted as the question of fire safety for batteries will be covered by relevant industry fire regulations.

CN5

(xi) we suggest that recycling standards for construction materials should be considered throughout the Plan rather than applied to renewable energy developments in isolation. For information, solar panels are classified as electronic equipment for purposes of the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) regulations imposed by the Environment Agency.

CN5

Add xii to restore the reference in the existing Local Plan to : “contribution to national, regional & sub-regional renewable energy targets.”

Micro energy generation schemes

CN6

ii The noise impacts should be more clearly defined with regard to noise level, distances and recipients.

Energy storage

CN7

(i). Co-location of generation and storage is desirable but not always possible because grid constraints exist in both directions (supply and distribution).

CN7

(iii). All large batteries require cooling fans. We suggest that noise concern is covered by (ii)

High quality, well designed and inclusive places

D1

Should include a reference to/ requirement for SUDS

D1

Point xi should be added, requiring proposals to demonstrate that the role of embodied carbon has been considered as part of the design process.

Design principles for Winchester Town

D2

We strongly support points vi and vii of this policy.

Masterplan

D5

Point vi, reduce the need for car use etc, should be the first point in this policy.

D5

Point xiv, assessing potential for including renewable energy schemes, should be prioritised at a very early stage of master planning.

Impact of overheating

D9

We strongly support the consideration of mechanical air conditioning as a last resort, and the requirement to include all the issues within the Energy and Carbon Statement.

Transport policies (to follow)
   
Open space, sport and recreation

NE3

This policy should include a much stronger requirement for community growing spaces to be included in all new development.  The onus should be on the developer to demonstrate if and why this is not achievable.

Open space provision for new developments

NE11

The policy should include a specific requirement for allotments/ community growing spaces to be included in residential developments of 10 or more dwellings.

Improvements or alterations to improve the energy efficiency of designated and non-designated historic assets

HE14

We strongly endorse this policy which provides in principle support for retrofitting of designated and non designated historic assets.

Para 10.19

We are pleased that both employment land and town centre/ retail and leisure studies, both undertaken before the COVID pandemic,  will be updated before the regulation 19 consultation of the Plan.

   

You can view the final responses submitted on behalf of WinACC on our page ‘WinACCs response to the local plan consultation in December 2022‘.

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: