Winchester City Council local elections 4th May 2023 – what was said at the Green Hustings?

WinACC’s open meeting on 29 April was a “Green Hustings” where representatives from each main political party answered questions about their positions on the climate emergency. These representatives were:

Cllr Malcolm Wallace (Greens – the first Green Party Member of the City Council)

Cllr Kelsie Learney (Lib Dems – current Cabinet Member for the Climate Emergency)

Ali Cochrane (Labour – candidate for St Luke’s ward)

Cllr Frank Pearson (Conservatives –  long-standing Conservative Councillor spokesperson on climate)

“Unless we do something, the planet will still exist but we won’t”

WinACC was very pleased at the responses from all four parties to the final question from WinACC’s Chair, which asked them to commit to work together with the other parties in the City Council to agree on the most important climate actions, and not to use it as an opportunity for party politicking. 

Cllr Learney for the Lib Dems said, “It would be fantastic if we could have a common agenda and agreement cross-party on our Carbon Neutrality Action Plan”, while warning that this didn’t mean she’d stop campaigning: ”We must work together, and campaign for what’s right”. All the others said they would be pleased to work together, with Cllr Pearson for the Conservatives summing up: “18-year-olds are going to have to experience a climate 2 degrees hotter. This is not political, it’s a statement of fact. We have got to work together. We only have one planet and unless we do something, the planet will still exist but we won’t. It’s as simple as that.”

Leaving fossil fuel in the ground

Questions about attitudes to renewable energy and ending use of fossil fuel showed the biggest difference across the parties. Cllr Pearson, the Conservative spokesperson, talked of compromise and being realistic –  “You can’t use farmland for solar energy when people need food” , whereas Cllr Wallace, the Green Party rep, said “Solar is key in Winchester District”, and argued for solar farms in the right place, plus rooftop solar, and powering down energy demand by retrofitting homes and setting high standards for new buildings. Ali Cochrane, on behalf of Labour, reminded us that electricity generation is dependent on national policy. Lib Dem Cllr Learney felt that solar is a big part of the solution, both large scale and rooftop new housing must be self-sufficient; they would also press for a major change in Government policy on wind, and improvements to energy infrastructure.

“We’re on a highway to hell with our feet on the accelerator”, said the questioner who asked about ending fossil fuel extraction. “We’ve got to get ourselves out of fossil fuels”, said Cllr Pearson, and all agreed. The Green and Lib Dem parties had worked together to oppose Hampshire County Council’s draft Minerals and Waste Plan, which would permit extraction locally. Cllr Pearson worried about alternatives to oil used for other products such as clothes, to which Ali Cochrane responded that we’ll only have innovation if we push for it, and we need to find alternatives to things made of plastic. 

Green, Labour and Lib Dem reps said they supported asking Hampshire Pension Fund to take its investments out of fossil fuels, adding that this was just part of a bigger need to increase investment in the green economy, which would create industry as well as addressing the climate crisis. Cllr Pearson described it as a pipedream, saying we must be pragmatic.

Public transport deserts

Asked what each would actually do to create a shift away from cars, all liked the idea of fewer cars on the roads and more space for pedestrians and cyclists, but there were many criticisms of the bus service for being too expensive, too unreliable, too slow, not frequent enough and not reaching all parts of the district. Cllr Wallace dubbed parts of the district as “public transport deserts”, backed by Cllr Pearson, who said, “I can’t walk 1km to the nearest bus stop. The bus service is not just for the city – for the district, it’s a miserable failure”.

Most spoke of the need to think about the best location for a bus interchange, and whether this should be close to the current bus station, or by the railways station, or both.

Cllr Learney listed things in hand, such as implementation of the schemes in the Winchester Movement Strategy, using the parking policy to drive behaviour change. Although the City Council provides electric vehicle charging points, Cllr Learney added that “Electric vehicles are not the solution. We can’t keep having more and more cars on the roads. The best thing you can do is get rid of that second vehicle”,  adding “I have access to loads of money for cycle racks so just let me know [where you’d like one]”. 

Winchester City and Hampshire County Councils face the challenge of finding tens of millions of pounds to make the changes needed – while the Government has just pulled the plug on its fund for more active travel. She also announced that the City Council is drafting its objection to the M3 scheme for Junction 9.   

On air pollution, Ali Cochrane said that Labour is pressing for the World Health Organisation targets to be made a legally enforced requirement: “If there is no way of avoiding it, it will be done”. Cllr Wallace, is on the Council’s Air Quality Steering Group. This aims to set more demanding targets, and will be sending out ideas for public review later this year. Cllr Learney supported the same aim: “We need to look at WHO levels which are set by people who care about public health not balancing health with car use”. 

Biodiversity and rivers

There was a wide variation in approach to the answers on biodiversity. Cllr Learney emphasised their determination to adopt an evidence-based approach, avoiding schemes that are tokenistic. Ali Cochrane took the opportunity to criticise the Government for rejecting the Labour motion for a water quality Bill. Cllr Wallace reminded listeners of the People’s Plan for Nature issued in March, and the legal duty to produce a nature recovery strategy. Cllr Pearson said that the Conservative Environment Act 2021 required any development to increase biodiversity by 10%, and spoke of the need to work with landowners.

A question on the health of local rivers showed how complicated this issue is. Answers showed little party differences, ranging from the need for national legislation, through run-off from farmland and industry overuse of nitrates and phosphates, to improving the way sewage is dealt with in private homes and Council estates, to the need to upgrade our infrastructure such as wider pipes.

Much agreement on recyclingThere was also considerable agreement about recycling, with the hope of being able to recycle hard plastic and other materials that aren’t recycled now, once the County Council open a new “Murf” [Materials recovery facility] in Eastleigh in summer 2025. The City Council’s plans to trial recycling food waste this year have been delayed following a Government announcement that they will make funds available for it, but only to Councils that aren’t doing it already. Cllr Pearson pointed out that we’ll need five different waste bins, which Cllr Learney said was “the price for recycling”. Ali Cochrane wanted the County Council to be more open about where our recycling goes. “Where does HCC take our recycling to? Why aren’t they telling us? We take time to recycle – take time to tell us”. Cllr Learney replied that the County Council has always made a commitment that it all ends up recycled, and said she’d ask “to make sure everything you put in the bin is recycled in a sensible and, we hope, low carbon way”.

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: