Solar Farm at Hursley, South Lynch: Planning Application

What you can do today as an individual:

WinACC is encouraging people resident in Winchester and the surrounding area to comment in support of this planning application, or renew their support if they have previously given it. Here is WinACC’s response

How to comment in support or renew your support:

Search for Reference 23/01025/FUL on the City Council’s planning portal. Click the ‘Comments’ tab on the screen and then the ‘make a comment’ box. Add your details and click ‘support’ at the ‘stance’ question.

You are free to leave any comments you wish. If you’re unsure what to say you could mention:

  • the declaration of a climate emergency by Winchester City Council
  • Improved screening in the revised plans
  • Improvements to biodiversity in the revised plans
  • That our energy security depends on all measures of renewable energy including solar farms.

We know that many people across the Winchester district support solar farms as an important part of the mix of renewable energy we need to generate to help prevent further pollution to our environment by the use of fossil fuels. This is your chance to ensure your voice is heard.

The deadline for comments is November 10.

Revised Plans (October 2023)

Some revisions to the original plans have been submitted, alongside improved photomontages of prospective views of the development.

Measures to screen these views and protect the landscape have been enhanced, increasing biodiversity net gain to 79% for habitat and 63% for hedgerow.

More details, together with clarification of important aspects of the plans, are set out in this Covering Letter submitted on behalf of the developer, Novus Renewable Services.

WinACC will reaffirm its support for the application. The amendments and clarifications respond to concerns expressed by local residents and by designated consultee organisations.

WinACC response to the revised plans for South Lynch Solar Farm

WinACC is satisfied that these revisions will reduce the impact of the development on the landscape.

We therefore reaffirm our support for this application for the reasons set out in our response in May 2023.

As prospects of stability in global energy supplies have deteriorated further since your first consultation, we must reiterate that every addition of local renewable generation will improve UK energy security. The public benefit of this development cannot be overstated.

******

The summary below was prepared to offer assistance for responses to the original planning application. The illustrations and extracts relate to the original plans.

 WinACC’s response to the original planning application and our overview about solar farms.

******

You can view the site from the vicinity of the crossroads junction of Sarum Road and Sparsholt Road. A higher resolution and interactive map is published by Winchester City Council.

About the Solar Farm (on land South Of Crab Wood, Sarum Road)

Solar Capacity: 20 MW

Land area of panels: 17.75 hectares (44 acres), reduced from the original plans for 23.5 hectares.

Support Structures: transformers, inverters, storage container, security fencing and an underground cable connection between the solar panels and two substations located at the southernmost point of the map, off Farley Mount Road.

Grid Connection: A grid connection agreement is in place for the project and, if planning permission is forthcoming, it could be connected to the network by the end of 2024.

Impact: The solar farm will generate over 3.5% of current demand for electricity in the District.

Duration: Operational lifespan of 40 years after which the the solar farm and associated infrastructure will be decommissioned, dismantled and removed (apart from one of the two substations which will be owned by the Distribution Network Operator).

About the Planning Application

Applicant: Novus Renewable Services

Planning Agent: Corylus Planning and Environmental

Expiry Date for Comments: 24th May, 2023

Parish: Hursley. The north boundary of the site is adjacent to Sparsholt parish.

WinACC Response

This is WinACC’s response to the application. You can contact us at renewables@winacc.org.uk.

******

Winchester Action on the Climate Crisis (WinACC) supports this application, as an essential response to the climate and energy crises, consistent with both national and local policies.

The development is relatively small for a solar farm. The area of the panels is only half that of the new solar farm at Three Maids Hill. But the contribution to grid decarbonisation is very significant, delivering 3.5% of our District’s consumption of electricity, equivalent to 5,500 average domestic rooftop systems. Subject to planning permission, the development could be operational as soon as the end of 2024.

Within the last month, the government’s Energy Security Plan, “Powering Up Britain”, commits to a fivefold scaling up of solar power by 2035. It acknowledges that “large scale ground-mount solar” must play a role and that “solar and farming can be complementary, supporting each other financially, environmentally and through shared use of land.”

Taken together with the City Council’s commitment to a carbon neutral district by 2030, this UK policy clarification tilts the core planning equation still further in favour of the public benefit of renewable energy, in relation to the impact of the solar farm. Suitable grid connections are very scarce and we must seize this opportunity.

We appeal to those who understandably wish to defend “unspoilt” landscapes and footpaths to come to terms with the reality of a warming planet. Within the 40-year duration of this development, climate change threatens both the character and visual experience of our landscapes far more than the intrusion of solar farms. Our estimates suggest that just 1.5% of the land area of our District would be sufficient to deliver a fair contribution towards the UK solar goal, if combined with a full complement of rooftop solar.

We also believe that the premise within the Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment that views of a solar farm inflict a negative reaction in all residents, walkers and cyclists has become oversimplified. A succession of recent national opinion polls, including the government’s Public Attitudes Tracker, suggest that the majority of households would welcome the prospect of a solar farm in their own locality.

******

Planning Application Documents

These summary notes offer quick reference to matters of particular importance. They are extracts copied from hundreds of pages of reports and are not presented as a substitute for them. The title of the relevant report is shown in italics. Apart from the topics summarised here, the reports include assessments relating to heritage, archaeology and flood risk. The Design and Access Statement provides a useful overall description in reader-friendly language and presentation.

Community Engagement

(extracts from the Statement of Community Involvement)

A four–page information leaflet providing an invitation to the community consultation events and information on the proposed development was mailed to 250 addresses of local residents and businesses within a 1.5km radius of the Site on 16th September 2022.

Representatives of Novus attended the Hursley Parish Council meeting on 26th September 2022. This included a presentation and question and answer session with the Parish Councillors prior to the Community Consultation Event.

…..a community drop–in consultation event…. was held at The IncuHive Space, Hursley Park Campus, Hursley Park Road, Winchester, SO21 2JN on Tuesday 4th October 2022 between 3pm and 7pm. Representatives from Novus, all with a variety of technical backgrounds, were available throughout the community consultation event to provide information and answer questions, as well as take note of any concerns raised.

…..the consultation boards were emailed to Sparsholt Parish Council (who responded) with an invitation to attend the Parish Council Meeting on 17th November 2022. Representatives from Novus attended this meeting.

Novus provide a community benefit fund for the local communities who will host the renewable energy and energy storage developments. …..the community benefit will be provided to (Hursley) Parish Council.

Landscape and Visual Impact

(extracts from the Summary section of the Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment)

The site is located within an undulating agricultural landscape mainly dominated by large scale farming and woodland……..The site is defined by Sarum Road (an historic roman road) on the northern boundary. Directly beyond Sarum Road is Crab Wood. This Semi Ancient woodland is a Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) and local nature reserve and forms part of the wider Farley Mount Country Park.

There are a handful of residential properties on Sarum Road which will likely have open views of the site. In addition, road users within the immediate vicinity, and in particular the Sarum Road / Sparsholt road crossroads, will have open views of the eastern edge of the development area. Filtered views and occasional open views of the development will be possible from the Clarendon Way public footpath and Sarum Road that run to the immediate north of the site.

In the wider landscape, it is predicted that the development will have more limited visual impact, primarily affecting views from the east.

The site itself contains no landscape features, land uses or habitats that are deemed to be significantly important or irreplaceable…..No listed buildings or scheduled monuments have been identified within the vicinity of the site. As part of this assessment the Farley Mount Obelisk was visited, and it is concluded that the proposals should have no impact on the setting of this heritage asset.

Mitigation proposals have been put forward to reduce or eliminate any potential adverse landscape and visual impacts caused by the development. The planting of the southern and eastern hedgerows and reinforcement of the existing northern and eastern field boundaries has been proposed to help screen and visually integrate the development from identified receptors.

Site map showing the 30m wildflower buffer between panels and north and west boundaries; and new hedgerows for south and east boundaries. Source: Corylus: Landscape Mitigation Plan

Without the planting mitigation in place (or prior to its establishment), the proposed development is predicted to have ‘major’ adverse visual impacts upon receptors at the Sarum Road residences and Farm shop……..the development is predicted to have a ‘minor’ to ‘moderate’ adverse visual impact on users of the Clarendon Way, with the solar farm visibility likely to be more obvious in the winter months. In the wider landscape, the visual impacts are likely to be ‘minor’ or ‘negligible’.

However, once the proposed screening mitigation has established and matured within a period of 8 to 10 years, it is predicted that the planting will help to reduce or eliminate, any adverse visual impacts caused by the development.

In respect of effects upon landscape character, the development is likely to have a ‘major’ impact within the site, and on those areas immediately outside of the site (including the residences on Sarum Road)…… …Notwithstanding the predicted adverse landscape impacts at the immediate site level, the proposed mitigation planting is likely to reduce any potential adverse impacts within the immediate vicinity of the site and within the wider landscape setting.  It is therefore considered that the overall long‐term adverse impacts upon landscape character within the wider visual envelope are likely to be relatively ‘minor’.

Agriculture

(extract from the Agricultural Land Classification).

.……the grading of the application site being:

Grade 2:       3.1 Ha    14%

Grade 3b:    19 Ha      86%

The topsoil at all sample points had varying amounts of small medium and large subrounded hard stone that would affect the type of cultivation and crops that could be grown and so would impact land grade.

The shallowness of the soils results in land grade being limited.

WinACC footnote: we have produced a short video on the relationship between solar farms and food security, Solar farms: A win-win for farmers, food and energy.

Biodiversity

(extracts from the Summary section of the Ecological Impact Assessment)

The majority of the proposed development site (i.e. arable land) was assessed as having low intrinsic nature conservation value, for most species. The hedgerows were assessed as being ecologically important at the local scale.

The survey found :

  1. a diverse breeding bird assemblage, with a number of red listed farmland bird species recorded, specifically skylark, which were considered likely to breed on the edge of the main site area.
  2. Brown hare were observed during bird surveys, in arable on and off-site.
  3. Bats, common reptiles and amphibians, badger, hazel dormice and other mammal species identified from local records could also utilise the hedgerows and field margins

All woody habitat (hedgerows, tree belt, copse etc.) will be retained and enhanced as part of the proposed development, and a stand-off from woody habitats will be integrated into the construction proposals. This will maintain the proposed development site’s suitability to support bats, hazel dormice, hedgerow nesting bird species and common reptiles and amphibians.

The provision of hedgerow habitat is considered distant enough from potential territories to not impact ground nesting birds. There is likely to be no significant impact upon breeding skylark at the local level, and only an exchange of one potential territory for enhanced foraging habitat within the site available to other nearby nesting pairs.

Overall, it is concluded that with the implementation of mitigation and compensation measures, and sensitive working methods set out within this report, the proposed development is unlikely to result in any significant negative impacts upon important ecological features. No contravention of relevant wildlife legislation is anticipated. The provision of ecological enhancements will provide biodiversity enhancement which has been calculated by the Defra Metric 3.1 to provide a net gain of 31.67% habitat units and 29.98% hedgerow units.

(further extracts from the Ecological Impact Assessment)

The site supports no habitat that could be considered supportive of that (Crab Wood) SSSI, its reasons for designation understood to be the woodland composition itself. With standard construction mitigations, proposed development at the site would not be of a form that could negatively impact those SSSI reasons at a distance. Specifically these factors means that there are no anticipated impacts (significant or otherwise) upon the Crab Wood SSSI.

Arable field margin is a UK priority habitat. However, the arable margins that were present (trackside and adjacent to arable) do not meet the criteria for priority habitat, as they are not deliberately managed to benefit biodiversity. Given the relatively species-poor and non-native botanical nature of the field margins, and abundance of similar habitat within the local area, the marginal habitat is considered to be of low ecological importance and has only limited site value to nature conservation.

The arable habitat was considered suboptimal, due to the monoculture and likelihood of insecticide spraying being a part of cultivation practices.

Following construction the previous arable habitat, below the panels and between rows, will be seeded with a diverse seed mix with the aim of creating good quality modified grassland around and between the panels and moderate quality modified grassland underneath.

The development proposes to create the following habitats that will benefit invertebrates:

  1. a grassland habitat, that will not be sprayed with insecticide;
  2. a ruderal / arable wildflower strip;
  3. ‘beetle bank’ ruderal bunds; and
  4. more planting of hedgerow / woody species will provide additional habitat and foraging

resource. 

Access

(extracts from the Construction Traffic Management Plan)

All (construction) traffic will be required to route to the site from the south, via the M3 junction 11, Badger Farm Road, the A3090, Sparsholt Road and Farley Mount Road.

Access to the site for construction purposes will occur via the existing access track and access onto Farley Mount Road. The existing access** measures approximately 4.7m wide and is currently used by large  agricultural vehicles, indicating a general suitability for HGVs.

The construction phase will take place over an estimated four months, with peak deliveries occurring in the first month. It is not forecast that there will be a requirement for any road closures on the local highway network.

The application site could expect to attract a maximum average of 32 two–way trips per day during the busiest phases of construction. This includes both deliveries made to the site by HGV and construction staff vehicles….The total number of daily vehicle trips presented does not represent a severe increase in vehicle trips on the local highway network.

**WinACC footnote: The plans include an extension to this access track from the farm buildings to meet the solar array area.

How to Support this Planning Application

  • Go to the City Council’s Planning home page and Log In (Register first, if you haven’t already done so)
  • Enter the Planning Reference Number (23/01025/FUL) in the search box.
  • Click on Comments, fill in your details, click ‘support‘ where it asks for stance, and post your comment in the text box as directed (you are welcome to copy and paste some of the information from this webpage if it is easier).

Join Us?

If you feel you can make a contribution to our solar farm advocacy and other energy projects, please consider joining our Renewable Energy Action Group.

We especially welcome knowledge and skills as follows:

  • Technical, commercial and local planning experience of renewable technologies at small/medium scale, especially solar
  • GIS software skills relevant to local area energy planning
  • Event delivery and marketing
  • Current and ex-parish councillors or community leaders in a position to help WinACC reach local communities for engagement with energy projects

Meetings are held every other month in Winchester, or virtually, usually on Monday evenings. Contact renewables@winacc.org.uk.

Find more posts in these categories:
Find more posts with these tags: